In the movie “Sliding Doors” (1998), a young woman either catches her Underground train or misses it. From that moment on, the movie tells two lives side by side. It shows how a small, chance moment sets a path in motion that becomes firmer with every further decision.
A first gold dot draws a slightly curved line around a small circle across a surface of mist-blue dots; further dots follow exactly this line until it becomes a strong gold track. Then the circle fades, a shorter, straight line appears beside it, only dashed in mist-blue, and the dots still stay in the curve.
Principle #81
Path Dependence: Early, often accidental decisions determine which paths remain open later; that is why beginnings matter more than they seem to at the time.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
The British movie, written and directed by Peter Howitt, plays out a thought experiment everyone knows: what if? It turns it into two parallel storylines. In doing so, it illustrates what the economist W. Brian Arthur calls Path Dependence, except that it does so within a single life rather than with technologies. This article also reveals the ending.
A path splits in front of a sliding door: a golden line slips through, a white one stays outside and turns off – as in “Sliding Doors.”
01
A door closes
Situation
Helen Quilley, played by Gwyneth Paltrow, works at a London PR agency and is fired one morning. She hurries to the Underground. In one version, she just makes the train. In the other, the doors close in front of her. At this point, the movie splits and goes on telling both lives in alternation.
Link to the principle
The starting point is tiny: a few seconds, a door. Nothing about it is planned or significant. Path dependence often begins like this, with an event that nobody thinks is important at the time.
02
Two lives from one moment
Situation
The Helen who catches the train gets home early and discovers that her boyfriend Gerry is cheating on her. She leaves him, meets the cheerful James and builds a new life with an agency of her own. The Helen who misses the train is mugged, ends up in the hospital and gets home too late to notice anything. She stays with Gerry and keeps her head above water with temporary jobs.
Link to the principle
One small difference turns into two different lives. The paths do not just diverge; they move further and further apart. That is the core of the principle: small initial differences grow because every later decision builds on the one before.
03
How the paths become fixed
Situation
In both storylines, Helen makes further decisions that fit her situation. One invests in her new company and her new relationship. The other settles into her old life and overlooks the signs that something is wrong. Each decision is understandable on its own.
Link to the principle
A path does not arise from a single step but from many steps that build on one another. With every decision, it becomes easier to stay on the path and harder to leave it. This applies to life stories just as it does to organizations that keep channeling their resources in one direction.
04
The ending brings the paths together
Situation
Toward the end, both Helens have an accident. One dies. The other survives, leaves Gerry after all and meets James, whom she has not yet met in this life. The movie thus suggests that some things happen on both paths, only at a different time.
Link to the principle
Here lies a limit that the movie itself shows. Not every difference at the start determines everything. Some developments prevail along different paths. Path dependence therefore does not mean that the beginning determines everything but that it strongly influences the path and the time it takes to reach the goal.
05
What the movie shows and what it doesn’t
Situation
“Sliding Doors” is a romantic comedy with tragic elements, not a treatise. Above all, it shows how sensitively a life story reacts to small beginnings. The mechanisms that hold a path in place in business and politics, such as habit, the effort of learning or comparability, appear only on the margins.
Link to the principle
For leaders, the movie is a good way to start a conversation: which small decisions have brought us to where we are? Which of them could have turned out differently? And which paths are closed to us today as a result, without our having noticed?
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Pay attention to small moments; they can set a path in motion.
02
Ask yourself which of your decisions build on earlier ones.
03
Check regularly whether you are still choosing a path or just continuing along it.
04
Be aware that staying will get easier and switching harder.
05
Keep in mind that other paths can also lead to the goal, only more slowly or more quickly.
Summary
“Sliding Doors” tells the two lives of one woman, which split apart because she catches or misses an Underground train. Through many decisions that build on one another, the small difference turns into two different paths. The ending partly brings the two back together. The movie thus vividly shows what path dependence means, and at the same time its limit: the beginning shapes the path, but it does not determine everything.
Sources
W. Brian Arthur: Competing Technologies, Increasing Returns, and Lock-In by Historical Events. In: The Economic Journal 99 (1989), No. 394, pp. 116–131.
Sliding Doors (United Kingdom/U.S. 1998), written and directed by Peter Howitt.
Back to the basics
Read what lies behind Path Dependence: with explanation, animation, video and research.