Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. The Council of Trent and the Strength of the Defense

Example of the principleStrength of the Defense (#37)

Faith & Religion

The Council of Trent and the Strength of the Defense

When the Reformation has taken hold of half of Europe, the Catholic Church first secures its doctrine and its order at the Council of Trent (1545–1563). From this consolidated position, the Counter-Reformation then begins.

A small golden circle stands behind an arc of fine lines; a large arrow of teal dots rolls in, crashes against it and loses dots with every impact, which fade to mist-blue. When the arrow has hardly any dots left, the arc opens, the golden circle stretches into a line and thrusts forward; in the final image, a second version shows an arrow going around the outside of the arc.
Principle #37

Strength of the Defense: Defense is the stronger form because time, terrain and preparation work for you; attack is the more effective one – so you hold firm first and then strike back at the right moment.

3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Under pressure, people often want to strike back at once. Carl von Clausewitz advises a different order, the order of the Strength of the Defense: first consolidate your own position, then attack from it. The Catholic Church in the 16th century is an example of an institution acting this way. This article describes it as a strategic process, without judging the theological questions on which the denominations still think differently today.

On the left, loose stones drift apart; in the middle, a solid foundation grows, and from its golden keystone the way leads on – as at Trent.
On the left, loose stones drift apart; in the middle, a solid foundation grows, and from its golden keystone the way leads on – as at Trent.

A church under pressure

Situation
Since Martin Luther’s theses of 1517, Protestant churches had formed in large parts of Germany, in Scandinavia, in Switzerland and beyond. Emperor Charles V wanted to calm the conflict because he needed the princes against France and the Ottoman Empire. Pope Paul III finally convened a council. It met in Trent, a city within the Empire and yet close to Italy, a compromise between emperor and pope. The Protestant estates did not take part in the deliberations. Envoys of some Protestant princes did come to Trent in 1551–52, but they demanded a free council not led by the pope.
Link to the principle
An organization under attack must first know what it stands for. Without a secure position, every counterattack becomes a shot in the dark.

Clear lines in doctrine

Situation
The council met in three periods over 18 years, with long interruptions and a temporary move to Bologna. It declared Holy Scripture and church tradition to be equal foundations of the faith. On the doctrine of justification, it held that human beings depend entirely on God’s grace but are to cooperate freely with it. In doing so, it deliberately set itself apart from the Protestant positions.
Link to the principle
Defense begins with clear lines. The council did not try to win over its opponents but to make its own position unmistakable. If you know your boundaries, you can hold them.

Order in its own house

Situation
At the same time, the council adopted internal reforms. It abolished the trade in indulgences, though indulgences themselves remained possible. Priests were to be trained in seminaries of their own. Bishops and parish priests had to live where they served and were no longer allowed to administer their offices from afar. The council ended on December 4, 1563; Pope Pius IV confirmed its decrees in 1564.
Link to the principle
A fortress holds only if its walls have no gaps. Many of the reformers’ criticisms concerned abuses. By tackling these itself, the council gave its critics less to attack and strengthened its own people.

From holding to counterattack

Situation
The decrees of Trent opened a period that church historians call the post-Tridentine era. On the basis of the council, a uniform catechism followed in 1566 and a uniform missal in 1570. In several regions of Europe, territories that had become Protestant became Catholic again, often with the help of their rulers. The term Counter-Reformation sums up this movement.
Link to the principle
Clausewitz describes the defense as a shield made up of well-directed blows, and the sudden, powerful transition to the attack as its greatest moment. Trent was the shield, the Counter-Reformation the return blow.

The limit

Situation
The council could not undo the division of the church. The church historian Hubert Jedin judged, in essence, that the council came just in time for the Romance-speaking countries but too late for the northern ones. There the new churches were already firmly rooted.
Link to the principle
Defense can hold what is still standing. What is already lost it rarely wins back. The earlier an organization consolidates its position, the more it can preserve.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Under pressure, first be clear about what you stand for.
  2. Close the gaps in your own house before you turn outward.
  3. Train your people; they are your walls.
  4. Go on the offensive only from a consolidated position.
  5. Don’t wait too long: defense preserves what is still standing, not what is already lost.
Summary

The Council of Trent (1545–1563) was the Catholic Church’s answer to the Reformation. It drew clear lines in doctrine and removed abuses in its own house, for example through seminaries for priests and the duty of residence. From this consolidated position, the Counter-Reformation began. The council could not heal the division, but it secured what was still standing. That is the principle of the Strength of the Defense: first consolidate your own position, then act from it.

Sources
  • Carl von Clausewitz: Vom Kriege (in German). 1832–1834.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Strength of the Defense: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: The Council of Trent and the Strength of the Defense.