Hemmed in by the Habsburg empire of Charles V, the Catholic king Francis I of France looks for an ally beyond his rival. He finds one in the Muslim sultan Suleiman I, the Habsburgs’ great opponent in the east. The alliance, which takes firm shape starting in 1536, shocks Christendom and follows the logic of the mandala exactly.
A golden dot in the middle, around which rings of small circles grow, alternating between teal for rivals and mist-blue for potential partners. A golden line runs from the center around a circle in the inner ring to a circle in the second ring; together they enclose the circle between them, and at the end the partner circle grows, moves inward and turns teal.
Principle #58
Mandala of States: Your neighbor is often your rival, and your rival’s neighbor is your natural ally.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
The ancient Indian Arthashastra contains a simple rule: your neighbor is your natural rival, your neighbor’s neighbor your natural friend. European rulers did not know the book. Yet in the 16th century, a French king acted as if he had read it. He put geography above faith and allied himself with the Ottoman Empire – a case of the Mandala of States.
A broad arc of dots clasps a golden dot, which stretches a line across it to the rival in the east – like Francis I and Suleiman I.
01
A king in captivity
Situation
On February 24, 1525, the troops of Emperor Charles V defeat the French army at Pavia in northern Italy. King Francis I is taken prisoner. To gain his freedom, he has to sign the Treaty of Madrid in 1526. In it, among other things, he renounces Burgundy and his claims in Italy.
Link to the principle
Francis experiences what an overwhelmingly powerful neighbor means. Charles V rules over Spain, the Netherlands, large parts of Italy and the Holy Roman Empire. France is surrounded by the Habsburgs on almost every side. On its own, it cannot break this ring.
02
The neighbor’s neighbor
Situation
To the east of the Habsburg sphere of power stands another mighty ruler: Sultan Suleiman I. In the 1520s, he extends Ottoman rule as far as Serbia. In 1526, he defeats Hungary at Mohács. After that, Charles’s brother Ferdinand claims the Hungarian crown, and Ottoman and Habsburg power collide head-on. In the Mediterranean, Ottoman fleets fight the Spanish ones.
Link to the principle
In the mandala, Suleiman is the neighbor of France’s neighbor. He has the same rival but no common border with France, and so no quarrel of his own with it. That is precisely what makes him the natural ally. Religion argues against it; the situation argues for it.
03
First contacts
Situation
While Francis is still in captivity, his mother, Louise of Savoy, sends a first embassy to the sultan. It is lost in Bosnia. In December 1525, a second embassy sets out under John Frangipani. It returns with a reply from Suleiman dated February 6, 1526, encouraging the French king not to lose heart.
Link to the principle
The first step in the mandala is recognizing shared interests. Both sides want to weaken the Habsburgs. Neither asks the other to give up its faith or its goals. The alliance rests on a single point: the common opponent in the middle.
04
The agreements of 1536
Situation
On February 18, 1536, the French envoy Jean de La Forêt negotiates what are known as the capitulations in Constantinople. They regulate trading rights and the protection of French merchants in the Ottoman Empire. On the Ottoman side, they were apparently not confirmed until 1569. Nevertheless, 1536 is regarded as the beginning of a firm alliance. In the fall of 1536, a joint fleet of French galleys and a small Ottoman squadron winters in Marseille. For the first time, a Turkish fleet spends the winter there.
Link to the principle
Common hostility turns into a lasting relationship. It sustains trade, diplomacy and occasional joint military campaigns. The mandala explains not only who allies with whom but also why such alliances can last a long time: as long as the rival remains in the middle, the interest remains.
05
Nice, Toulon and the scandal
Situation
In August 1543, about 110 Ottoman galleys, together with French ships, besiege Nice, which belongs to Savoy. In the winter of 1543–44, Francis lets the Ottoman fleet use the port of Toulon as its quarters. For a time, the cathedral serves as a mosque. In May 1544, the Ottomans leave after Francis has paid a large sum. In Christendom, the alliance is regarded as a scandal. Charles V calls on the rest of Europe to oppose the French king’s alliance with the sultan.
Link to the principle
The mandala has a price. If you choose your neighbor’s neighbor, you often choose a partner who is alien to your own people. Francis pays with his reputation. Even so, the alliance holds in changing forms for more than two and a half centuries, until Napoleon’s Egyptian campaign in 1798.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Look at the map before you decide who your friends and opponents are.
02
Your rival’s rival has an interest of their own in helping you.
03
An alliance doesn’t need a shared worldview, just one point in common.
04
Factor in the price: unusual partners cost you reputation.
05
Such alliances last as long as the common opponent remains.
Summary
Francis I was hemmed in by the Habsburgs. He looked for an ally not among his neighbors but in his rival’s neighbor: the Ottoman Empire. The alliance, which took firm shape starting in 1536, contradicted the faith of the time but followed the logic of the situation. It shows the Mandala of States in its purest form, along with its price.