Guy Laliberté, Cirque du Soleil and the Blue Ocean
In 1984, former street performers in Quebec found Cirque du Soleil. They leave out what makes the classic circus expensive and vulnerable, above all the animals, and add what until then only the theater offered: themes, stories, artistic music. The result is a new market between circus and theater.
Many small teal dots crowd in a tight circle around a mist-blue swarm and collide. At the turning point, one dot drops three mist-blue splinters, turns gold and travels on an arc out into a wide, empty frame in which new gold dots light up; in the final image other dots follow, and the edge of the frame grows dense again.
Principle #72
Blue Ocean: Instead of fighting everyone for the same customers, you create a new space without competition by eliminating what everyone takes for granted and adding what does not yet exist.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Cirque du Soleil is W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne’s best-known example. They place it at the beginning of their work on blue oceans, first in an article in the Harvard Business Review in 2004, then in their 2005 book. They use it to show how a company in a shrinking industry grows without poaching customers from the established players – the Blue Ocean in its classic form.
A circus ring of dots and a stage with a curtain overlap, and the shared area shines gold – as with Cirque du Soleil.
01
From stilt walkers to circus
Situation
Guy Laliberté and Gilles Ste-Croix belong to a group of street performers who travel through Quebec as stilt walkers from 1979 to 1983. In 1983, Laliberté receives a grant of 1.6 million Canadian dollars from the provincial government for a performance marking the 450th anniversary of Jacques Cartier’s arrival in North America. On June 16, 1984, Cirque du Soleil is founded in Baie-Saint-Paul. Its first show tours Quebec for 13 weeks that summer.
Link to the principle
The founders do not come from the circus industry but from the street. They have no ingrained ideas about what a circus has to be. That makes it easier to question the industry’s rules.
02
A red ocean
Situation
Kim and Mauborgne describe the classic circus of the time as an industry with declining audiences. Children would rather play video games, animal rights groups criticize the animal acts, and well-known performers have strong bargaining power. The established circuses compete with similar programs for a shrinking audience.
Link to the principle
This is what a red ocean looks like. If you compete there with more spectacle, more animals or better-known clowns, you only intensify the fight for the same audience. Cirque du Soleil chooses a different path.
03
Eliminating and keeping
Situation
According to Kim and Mauborgne, Cirque du Soleil does without the expensive animal acts and big stars. It keeps what is at the heart of the circus: the tent, the clowns, the acrobatics.
Link to the principle
The authors’ four questions are: what will you eliminate, what will you reduce, what will you raise, what will you create? Eliminating lowers costs markedly. Animals need care, transport and housing. At the same time, doing without them takes the wind out of the critics’ sails.
04
Adding what the theater offers
Situation
Instead of a string of individual acts, Cirque du Soleil presents productions with their own theme, their own story and their own music. In 1987, the show “Le Cirque Réinventé” is invited to the Los Angeles Arts Festival and brings in a profit of more than 1.5 million dollars by the end of the year. In December 1993, the resident show “Mystère” opens in Las Vegas.
Link to the principle
What is added comes from another market, the theater. With it, Cirque du Soleil reaches above all adults and corporate clients, who, according to Kim and Mauborgne, pay several times the prices of classic circuses. The authors call this value innovation: lower costs and higher value at the same time, instead of the usual choice between the two.
05
Size and vulnerability
Situation
According to Wikipedia, more than 100 million people worldwide have seen Cirque du Soleil productions. In 2015, Laliberté sells 90% of the shares to a group of investors. In March 2020, because of the COVID-19 pandemic, the company has to halt all 44 running shows and temporarily lays off around 95% of its workforce. In June 2020, it files for creditor protection, and in November it is sold to a group of creditors.
Link to the principle
A blue ocean protects against competition, not against every crisis. An offering that relies entirely on live performances is vulnerable when gatherings are banned. Even the best new market needs reserves.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Question the rules of your industry, especially if you come from outside.
02
Leave out what is expensive and means little to customers.
03
Keep what makes up the core of your offering.
04
Bring in something new from a neighboring market.
05
A new market is no substitute for reserves for a crisis.
Summary
Cirque du Soleil grew in a shrinking industry because it did not compete with the old circuses. It left out animals and stars, kept the tent, clowns and acrobatics, and added theme, story and music from the theater. In this way, a new market emerged, which W. Chan Kim and Renée Mauborgne made the textbook example of the blue ocean.
W. Chan Kim, Renée Mauborgne: Blue Ocean Strategy: How to Create Uncontested Market Space and Make the Competition Irrelevant. Boston: Harvard Business School Press 2005.