In the 19th century, two families on the border between West Virginia and Kentucky fight each other for decades. Every act is avenged, none is forgiven, and more than a dozen people die. The feud shows what becomes of the principle when forgiveness is missing.
Two dots take turns sending arcs to each other; golden arcs make a line grow between them, a teal arc makes it buckle. After a clear teal response and an immediate golden arc, the line straightens and branches out in gold, while a second pair below, after the first break, only exchanges pale arcs and lets nothing grow between them.
Principle #62
Tit for Tat: Start friendly, respond clearly to betrayal and forgive quickly – then cooperation can grow and last even between rivals.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Tit for Tat has two halves. One says: respond to betrayal. The other says: forgive as soon as the other side relents. Robert Axelrod’s computer tournaments show that only both halves together sustain cooperation. The feud between the Hatfields and the McCoys is the opposite case: an object lesson in retaliation without forgiveness.
Arrows fly back and forth across a river, each one longer, while a small golden dot remains untouched – like the feud between the Hatfields and the McCoys.
01
Two families on the Tug Fork
Situation
The Hatfields live mainly on the West Virginia side, the McCoys on the Kentucky side, separated by the Tug Fork River. The family heads are William Anderson Hatfield, known as “Devil Anse,” and Randolph McCoy, known as Randall. In January 1865, Asa Harmon McCoy is killed shortly after returning from the Union Army. A group of Confederate irregulars claims responsibility; there are no records. McCoy family tradition blames a relative of the Hatfields.
Link to the principle
A feud often begins with a deed whose circumstances no one knows for sure. If you interpret it as betrayal, you respond. Whether it was betrayal soon stops mattering. What matters is that both sides believe they have a score to settle.
02
A hog and a witness
Situation
In 1878, the families go to court over a hog. Randall McCoy claims that Floyd Hatfield took it from him. A justice of the peace from the Hatfield family rules in favor of the Hatfields; a key witness is Bill Staton, who is related to both families. In June 1880, Staton is killed by two McCoys, who are later acquitted on grounds of self-defense.
Link to the principle
This is where the echo Axelrod describes begins. A dispute over something of little value becomes a question of honor. Each side sees itself as the one that is only responding. Neither sees itself as the one that started it.
03
The spiral of retaliation
Situation
On Election Day in 1882, three of Randall McCoy’s sons clash with Ellison Hatfield. Ellison is badly wounded, stabbed many times and shot. The Hatfields seize the three brothers and take them to West Virginia. When Ellison dies, they shoot the three. On New Year’s night 1888, Hatfield men surround the McCoy house, fire on the sleeping family and set the house on fire. Calvin and Alifair McCoy die; Randall’s wife, Sarah, is badly beaten.
Link to the principle
This is retaliation without measure and without end. In Tit for Tat, you respond once and exactly as strongly as the deed. In the feud, every response is harsher than the deed it answers. That is why there is no point at which one side could say: now we’re even.
04
The law steps in
Situation
A deputy sheriff from Kentucky leads a posse chasing the Hatfields across the state line, and a gunfight breaks out at Grapevine Creek. In 1888, eight men are charged with the murder of Alifair McCoy. The U.S. Supreme Court rules that Kentucky may try them, even though they were brought across the state line irregularly. All are convicted; seven receive life sentences, and Ellison Mounts is hanged in Pikeville. By May 1891, the feud is considered over.
Link to the principle
The feud ends not through forgiveness but through a third party. Where two parties do not break the cycle themselves, someone from outside has to break it. That is costly and comes late.
05
Reconciliation, 112 years later
Situation
On June 14, 2003, more than 60 descendants of both families sign a truce in Pikeville. The governors of Kentucky and West Virginia declare June 14 a day of reconciliation.
Link to the principle
The second half of the principle, forgiveness, comes more than a century too late here. It is valuable nonetheless. It shows that ultimately only a deliberate act ends the cycle, not the next response.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Respond to an injury, but no more strongly than the injury itself.
02
Ask yourself whether you are responding or just carrying on.
03
Forgiveness is not a sign of weakness but the way out of the spiral.
04
Create a point at which both sides can say: now we’re even.
05
If you can’t get out on your own, bring in a third party.
Summary
The feud between the Hatfields and the McCoys lasted from 1863 to 1891 and claimed more than a dozen lives. Every act was avenged, every response was harsher than the act before, and no one forgave. This makes it the opposite of Tit for Tat: retaliation without measure and without forgiveness destroys both sides. Only the courts ended the violence, and only in 2003 did reconciliation follow.