Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Jean-Marc Bosman, the Bosman Ruling and the Best Alternative

Example of the principleBest Alternative (#69)

Arts, Entertainment & Sports

Jean-Marc Bosman, the Bosman Ruling and the Best Alternative

In 1990, the Belgian soccer player Jean-Marc Bosman wants to move to a French club after his contract expires, but his club blocks him. The 1995 ruling of the European Court of Justice gives all professionals in the EU an alternative they did not have before, and with it changes every contract negotiation in soccer.

Two dots sit on a horizontal line with a small frame between them as the offer; behind one a gold gate opens into the light, behind the other stands a closed mist-blue line. Then the second dot draws a gate of its own into its line, and the frame moves to the middle.
Principle #69

Best Alternative: Your power in a negotiation depends above all on how well off you are if there is no agreement.

3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

How strong someone is in a negotiation does not depend only on their ability. It depends on what they can do if they say no. For professional soccer players in Europe, the answer until 1995 was: not much. A midfielder from Belgium changed that and paid for it with his career – a lesson in the Best Alternative.

Between two playing fields stands a fence of dots; a gold gap opens, and dots pass through it – as with the Bosman ruling.
Between two playing fields stands a fence of dots; a gold gap opens, and dots pass through it – as with the Bosman ruling.

Trapped after the contract ends

Situation
Jean-Marc Bosman played for the Belgian club RFC Liège. In June 1990, his contract expired. The club offered him a new contract on much worse terms. Bosman refused and wanted to move to the French second-division club USL Dunkerque. Under the rules of the time, Liège could demand a transfer fee even after his contract had ended. The clubs could not agree, and the move fell through. Bosman was stuck.
Link to the principle
Bosman had no real alternative. Without an agreement with his old club, he could not play anywhere. That is why Liège could make him a bad offer. If you have no alternative, you have to take what you are offered, or you lose everything.

The road to court

Situation
Bosman sued in the Belgian courts. In 1993, the case was referred to the European Court of Justice. On December 15, 1995, the court ruled that transfer rules for players whose contracts had expired, and quotas on players from other EU countries, violated the freedom of movement for workers.
Link to the principle
The ruling created a new alternative for all professionals in the EU: moving on a free transfer once their contract had ended. This shifted the balance of strength at every negotiating table, even for players who would never change clubs.

The final year of the contract

Situation
Since the ruling, players have gained leverage in the last year of their contracts. The club must either extend their contract on better terms or sell them while it can still get a fee. Otherwise the player leaves for nothing. Well-known free transfers include Steve McManaman from Liverpool to Real Madrid in 1999, Sol Campbell from Tottenham Hotspur to Arsenal in 2001 and Robert Lewandowski from Borussia Dortmund to Bayern Munich in 2014.
Link to the principle
The alternative does not have to be used to have an effect. The mere fact that it exists changes the negotiation. Clubs offer longer contracts, higher salaries and signing bonuses earlier in order to forestall a free transfer.

The clubs respond

Situation
The clubs adapted. They signed longer contracts to push back the point of a free transfer. They sold players more often a year before their contracts ran out. Overall, salaries in the top leagues rose sharply, and power shifted from the clubs to the players and their agents.
Link to the principle
When one side’s alternative improves, the other looks for new ways to strengthen its own. Negotiating power is not a fixed state but an interplay. If you have the better alternative today, you have to be prepared for the other side to catch up tomorrow.

The price for Bosman

Situation
Bosman himself hardly benefited. The legal battle lasted more than five years. By the time the ruling came, his professional career was practically over.
Link to the principle
If you fight for a better alternative for everyone, you often pay for it yourself. Bosman’s story is a reminder that negotiating power sometimes arises only through rules that someone pushes through against great resistance. The best alternative is not only a question of your own situation but also of the framework in which the negotiation takes place.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Before every negotiation, ask yourself what you can do if you say no.
  2. If you have no alternative, work on creating one.
  3. Watch out for rules that limit your alternative; sometimes they can be changed.
  4. Use the moment when your alternative is strongest.
  5. Be prepared for the other side to respond to your stronger alternative.
Summary

Before 1995, a soccer club could hold on to a player even after his contract had ended, because it was allowed to demand a transfer fee. Jean-Marc Bosman fought this all the way to the European Court of Justice and won. Since then, professionals in the EU have had a real alternative once their contracts end. That has changed every contract negotiation, even where nobody moves on a free transfer. Bosman himself paid for it with his career.

Sources
  • Guide to Football: The Bosman Ruling
  • European Court of Justice: Judgment of December 15, 1995, Case C-415/93 (Bosman).
  • Wikipedia: Bosman ruling
  • Roger Fisher and William Ury: Getting to Yes: Negotiating Agreement Without Giving In. Boston: Houghton Mifflin 1981.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Best Alternative: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Jean-Marc Bosman, the Bosman Ruling and the Best Alternative.