Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Movie: Dunkirk

Example of the principleEconomy of Force (#9)

Government & Politics

Movie: Dunkirk

Christopher Nolan’s 2017 film tells the story of the 1940 rescue of soldiers trapped at Dunkirk, seen from three perspectives. In the air, only three Spitfires are fighting. There is a reason there are so few: the leadership of the Royal Air Force wants to keep enough fighters for the defense of Britain.

A large circle in the center and two small circles at the edge receive equal numbers of mist-blue dots from a single source; the large one stays pale while the small ones overflow. Restart: the outer circles get a few targeted dots, just enough to stay teal, and the main stream goes into the center circle, which grows golden; when one outer circle briefly fades, a single dot saves it.
Principle #9

Economy of Force: Give secondary theaters only as much as they need to hold, so that the main theater gets enough.

3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

“Dunkirk” is a film with little dialogue and three timelines: a week on the mole, a day at sea, an hour in the air. Nolan does not explain any strategy. He shows how a strategic decision feels to the people who are stationed in its secondary theater. That is precisely what makes the film so well suited to seeing Economy of Force from below.

Only three golden dots trace their paths over the beach and the boats, while a reserve stays put on the distant coast – as in “Dunkirk.”
Only three golden dots trace their paths over the beach and the boats, while a reserve stays put on the distant coast – as in “Dunkirk.”

The situation on the beach

Situation
At the end of May 1940, German troops have trapped British and French forces on the Channel coast near Dunkirk. In the film, young soldiers like Tommy, played by Fionn Whitehead, wait on the mole and on the beach while German aircraft sink ships. Civilians like Mr. Dawson, played by Mark Rylance, cross the Channel in their own boats to help.
Link to the principle
On the beach, every bit of help seems too small. To the soldiers, Dunkirk is the most important place in the world. To the high command, it is an important theater, but not the decisive one. This tension carries the entire film.

Three planes, one hour

Situation
Three Spitfires fly across the Channel. The flight leader is lost early on. Collins, played by Jack Lowden, has to ditch in the sea. Farrier, played by Tom Hardy, flies on even though his fuel gauge is smashed and his fuel is running low. He attacks German aircraft that are threatening the ships and the beach.
Link to the principle
The three Spitfires are the image of a secondary theater that gets exactly as much as it needs to prevent the worst. Every plane counts, because there are so few.

The decision in the background

Situation
Historically, as early as May 1940, Hugh Dowding, head of the Royal Air Force’s Fighter Command, had warned against sending more fighter squadrons to France. He wanted to keep enough aircraft for the defense of Britain. The RAF flew its missions over Dunkirk from airfields in England. The film does not explain this decision, but it shows its consequence: few aircraft over a vast area.
Link to the principle
This is the heart of the principle. The secondary theater gets only as much as it needs to hold, so that enough remains for the main theater. That main theater arrived a few weeks later with the Battle of Britain in the summer of 1940.

Down to the last drop

Situation
As Farrier’s fuel runs out, he still shoots down a dive bomber attacking the mole. With his engine dead, he glides over the beach and lands far from his own lines. He destroys his plane so that it does not fall into enemy hands, and he is taken prisoner.
Link to the principle
Economy of Force also means using scarce resources to the very last. Carl von Clausewitz warned against letting forces stand idle. If you have little, you have to commit every unit fully. Farrier leaves nothing unused.

The homecoming

Situation
On the train home, Alex fears that the returning soldiers will be reviled as failures. Instead, the people of Woking welcome them warmly. Tommy reads aloud a newspaper report of the speech the new prime minister, Winston Churchill, gave in Parliament: Britain will fight on.
Link to the principle
Economy of Force comes at a price in how it is perceived. If you are stationed in the secondary theater, you mostly see what was missing, and you expect reproach. What was achieved there with few resources often becomes clear only in the bigger picture. Leaders have to bear this tension and, where possible, explain it.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Distinguish which theater is important and which is decisive.
  2. Give the secondary theater enough to prevent the worst.
  3. Use scarce resources there to the very last.
  4. Hold back the bulk of your forces for what is still to come.
  5. Explain your allocation to those stationed in the secondary theater.
Summary

“Dunkirk” shows the rescue from Dunkirk through the eyes of those on the beach, at sea and in the air. Only three Spitfires fly over the beach, because the Royal Air Force wants to keep enough fighters for the defense of Britain. The film makes you feel what Economy of Force means for the people in the secondary theater: few resources, total commitment and the sense of being left on your own while the real decision is still to come.

Sources
  • Dunkirk. Directed by Christopher Nolan. United Kingdom, U.S. 2017.
  • Walter Lord: The Miracle of Dunkirk. New York: Viking 1982.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Economy of Force: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Movie: Dunkirk.