Shortly after takeoff in New York, both engines of an Airbus fail. The standard plan would be to return to the airport. Captain Chesley Sullenberger rejects it and lands on the Hudson. All 155 people on board survive. The film shows when you have to abandon a plan, and how to do it with discipline.
A dashed line connects a starting point with a golden target circle. A dot sets off until a crossbar cuts the line and it fades to mist-blue. The target circle keeps glowing; a new arc in teal traces itself around the obstacle, later a second one, and the dot reaches the target by a completely different route.
Principle #21
Plan and Adaptation: A plan gives you direction, but as soon as reality responds, you have to adapt it without losing sight of the objective.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
“Sully” (2016), directed by Clint Eastwood from a screenplay by Todd Komarnicki, tells the story of the emergency landing of US Airways Flight 1549 on January 15, 2009. It is based on the autobiography “Highest Duty,” which Chesley Sullenberger wrote with the journalist Jeffrey Zaslow. The film is not a disaster movie but a film about a decision and the question of whether it was right. That makes it a powerful illustration of the Principle of Plan and Adaptation.
The dashed arc back to the runway fades; the golden path glides down onto the wide river beside the city – as in “Sully.”
01
A routine flight
Situation
Captain Chesley “Sully” Sullenberger (Tom Hanks) and his first officer, Jeff Skiles (Aaron Eckhart), take off in an Airbus A320 from New York’s LaGuardia Airport. During the climb, the plane flies into a flock of birds. Both engines are badly damaged and lose power.
Link to the principle
There are plans for engine failure: checklists, procedures and the rule to head for an airport if at all possible. These plans are good. But they assume that there is enough altitude, time and distance left. Whether that is the case here, the crew has to judge in seconds.
02
The plan doesn’t fit
Situation
The options are a return to LaGuardia or the smaller Teterboro Airport. Sullenberger and Skiles conclude that they cannot safely reach either. Sullenberger decides to ditch in the Hudson River. The landing succeeds; passengers and crew stand on the wings and are picked up by ferries and rescue boats.
Link to the principle
Here Sullenberger abandons the standard plan because reality doesn’t fit it. The objective remains unchanged: to get everyone on board down safely. Only the way changes. Adaptation here does not mean improvising blindly, but making a clear judgment about when the prepared way no longer holds.
03
Discipline in adaptation
Situation
The film shows that, despite the emergency, the cockpit keeps working by procedure. Skiles works through the checklist for engine failure, the two coordinate in a few words, and Sullenberger informs the cabin and air traffic control. The departure from the plan happens not in chaos but in orderly cooperation.
Link to the principle
Good adaptation doesn’t throw everything away. It keeps the parts of the plan that still fit and replaces only the part that no longer works. Experience and routine are what create the room in which a wise departure becomes possible.
04
The simulations
Situation
After the landing, Sullenberger is celebrated as a hero. At the same time, the National Transportation Safety Board (NTSB) investigates the incident. In the film, its computer simulations and initial engine data suggest that a return to LaGuardia would have been possible. Sullenberger objects that the pilots in the simulators knew what was coming and turned back immediately. When the simulation is repeated with a delay of 35 seconds for recognizing and deciding, the planes crash.
Link to the principle
This scene shows a typical error in thinking. In hindsight, with full knowledge, the plan always looks feasible. But anyone who is actually in the situation first has to grasp what is happening. A plan that doesn’t allow for that time is good only on paper. If you evaluate adaptations, you have to see the situation as it was at the time.
05
The verdict
Situation
At the end of the film, the investigation confirms that the left engine was badly damaged and that Sullenberger acted correctly. The film was criticized, however, for portraying the investigators as too hostile. Real NTSB investigators disputed this portrayal, among them the former lead investigator Robert Benzon.
Link to the principle
The film itself also adapts reality to create suspense. For the principle, that is a useful reminder: if you have to justify a departure from the plan, you are often under pressure. That makes it all the more important to be able to state the reasons for an adaptation clearly.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
A standard plan presupposes certain conditions; check whether they apply.
02
Hold on to the objective when you leave the way.
03
In adapting, keep everything that still fits.
04
Judge decisions by the situation as it was then, not as it looks today.
05
Be prepared to justify your departure from the plan clearly.
Summary
“Sully” shows a captain who rejects the standard plan because it doesn’t hold in the situation and who finds a better way through discipline and experience. The film also shows how easily, in hindsight, we consider a plan feasible that would not have worked in real time. That is the Principle of Plan and Adaptation: the objective is fixed, and the way follows reality.