Steven Spielberg, Jaws and the Principle of Plan and Adaptation
In 1974, the young Steven Spielberg is shooting a film about a great white shark. The mechanical shark keeps failing in the salt water. So Spielberg barely shows it and only hints at it. The breakdown turns into the suspense that makes “Jaws” the most successful film of its time in 1975.
A dashed line connects a starting point with a golden target circle. A dot sets off until a crossbar cuts the line and it fades to mist-blue. The target circle keeps glowing; a new arc in teal traces itself around the obstacle, later a second one, and the dot reaches the target by a completely different route.
Principle #21
Plan and Adaptation: A plan gives you direction, but as soon as reality responds, you have to adapt it without losing sight of the objective.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Helmuth von Moltke knew that a plan rarely survives its first encounter with reality unchanged. For Steven Spielberg, that reality was the Atlantic. His story, an example of the Principle of Plan and Adaptation, shows that adaptation sometimes does more than limit the damage: it produces something better than the plan ever envisaged.
Above the waterline, only a golden fin traces its path; the large shape beneath remains dashed – as in Spielberg’s “Jaws.”
01
A plan with a mechanical star
Situation
The producers Richard D. Zanuck and David Brown secure the rights to Peter Benchley’s novel “Jaws” and bring in Steven Spielberg, still young at the time, as director. The film is to show a great white shark. For this, they have three mechanical sharks built, nicknamed “Bruce” by the crew and looked after by the special effects expert Robert Mattey. Shooting begins off Martha’s Vineyard in May 1974; 55 shooting days are planned.
Link to the principle
The plan stands or falls with a machine. It is the star of the film. Spielberg deliberately shoots on the open sea rather than in a studio tank, because he wants authenticity. In doing so, he exposes his plan to a reality he does not control.
02
Salt water
Situation
Before long, the sharks keep failing. Their pneumatic hoses take in salt water; the technology suffers in the seawater and breaks down. On top of that come other problems at sea. At one point, the boat Orca starts to sink with the actors on board.
Link to the principle
This is Moltke’s first encounter with the enemy’s main force. The plan was well thought out, but it was built on a condition that turned out to be false. Spielberg cannot change the Atlantic. He can only change how he deals with it.
03
The shark you don’t see
Situation
Spielberg begins to merely suggest the shark. Yellow barrels attached to harpoons show where the animal is underwater. Often all you see is the dorsal fin, or you look at the swimmers’ legs from the shark’s point of view. This moves the film away from the monster movie and closer to the suspense cinema of Alfred Hitchcock. John Williams’s score, a simple, building two-note motif, announces the shark before it appears. Spielberg later said, in essence, that the broken shark had been a stroke of luck.
Link to the principle
This is the heart of the matter. Spielberg holds on to the objective, a film that fills the audience with fear. But he gives up the way he had planned. The new solution is better than the old one: what you don’t see, your imagination fills with its own terror. Adaptation turns a weakness into a strength.
04
A system of expedients
Situation
The shoot becomes a permanent makeshift. According to the producers’ plans, it was to last 55 days; in the end it takes 159. The budget grows from a planned $3.5 to $4 million to about $9 million. The writer Carl Gottlieb rewrites almost the entire screenplay during filming. Later, the editor Verna Fields shapes the film’s suspense in the cutting room.
Link to the principle
Moltke called strategy a system of expedients. That is exactly what emerges here. Adaptation is not a one-time decision but daily work. And it has a price: time, money and nerves. If you adapt, you have to be able to bear these costs.
05
The success
Situation
“Jaws” opens in North America on June 20, 1975, on 464 screens at once, an unusually wide release for the time. The film breaks records and is the first to earn $100 million in theatrical rentals in the United States. It wins three Oscars, including for editing and music.
Link to the principle
The success comes not in spite of the adaptation but in large part because of it. The Oscars for editing and music in particular show where the answer to the shark’s failure lay. Had Spielberg insisted on the original plan, he would probably have made a worse film.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Check under what conditions your plan has really been tested.
02
Hold on to the objective when the way fails.
03
Ask yourself whether a breakdown makes a better solution possible.
04
Adaptation is daily work, not a single decision.
05
Remember that adaptation has a price, and plan reserves for it.
Summary
Steven Spielberg planned a film with a mechanical shark as its star. In the salt water, the technology failed again and again. So Spielberg only hinted at the shark, with barrels, fins and music, and created a suspense the plan would never have achieved. The film became a record-breaking success. That is the Principle of Plan and Adaptation: the objective stays, and the way follows reality.