Two economists analyze 2.5 million putts on the PGA Tour. Professionals sink par putts more often than birdie putts of the same length, because a bogey feels like a loss and a birdie merely like a gain.
Two circles of equal size, one with a plus, one with a minus, lie at the ends of a horizontal line balanced on a small triangle, and the line tips clearly toward the circle with the minus. Then the line becomes a kinked curve, rising gently to the right and falling steeply to the left, and a gold dot as the reference point moves along it and shifts what counts as a gain and what counts as a loss.
Principle #82
Loss Aversion: A loss hurts more than an equal gain pleases, and that is why people fight harder for what they have than for what they could get.
4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
If you want to prove Loss Aversion, you need people who are experienced, face competition and can earn a lot of money. Among such people, biases ought to disappear. The economists Devin G. Pope and Maurice E. Schweitzer chose exactly such people: the best golfers in the world. Their result shows how deep the principle runs.
Two balls lie the same distance from the hole; the golden par putt drops in, the birdie putt stops just short – as with the pro golfers.
01
A sport with a built-in reference point
Situation
In golf, every hole has a target score, par. If you play a hole in one stroke fewer, you make a birdie. If you need one stroke more, you make a bogey. For the overall result of a tournament, every stroke is worth the same. Whether you drop a stroke on a birdie putt or on a par putt makes no difference on the scorecard.
Link to the principle
Par provides a natural reference point. Staying under par is a gain; ending up over it is a loss. If loss aversion is at work, players should try harder on a par putt than on a birdie putt, even though both count the same.
02
2.5 million putts
Situation
Pope and Schweitzer analyzed about 2.5 million putts, played by 421 professionals at 239 PGA Tour tournaments between 2004 and 2009. The PGA Tour records the position of every ball by laser measurement. This allowed the researchers to compare putts from the same distance and the same position. The result: birdie putts went in about two percentage points less often than comparable par putts. The study was published in 2011 in the American Economic Review.
Link to the principle
Two percentage points may not sound like much. But the gap appears among people who practice every day and make their living from the result. The players behave differently depending on whether a miss puts them below or above the reference point. This is loss aversion under ideal conditions.
03
Other explanations tested
Situation
The researchers tested the obvious objections. Perhaps a birdie putt typically lies in a worse position, because after a good approach shot the ball is often farther from the hole? The researchers took into account, among other things, distance, position on the green, the difficulty of the hole and what a player could learn from earlier putts on the same green. The difference remained.
Link to the principle
What remains is the different evaluation of gain and loss. According to the study, the professionals leave birdie putts short more often than par putts; in other words, they play them more cautiously. They would rather secure par than risk overshooting in going for the birdie. On a par putt, by contrast, they are determined to avoid the loss.
04
Even Tiger Woods
Situation
The title of the study asks whether Tiger Woods is loss averse. The answer: even the best players show the pattern, especially in the early rounds of a tournament. By the researchers’ calculations, the bias costs an average professional more than one stroke per tournament. Without it, the top 20 players in 2007 would each have earned around $640,000 more in prize money on average.
Link to the principle
Experience does not protect you. Competition does not protect you. High stakes do not protect you. This is crucial for strategy: professionals on the other side, whether in a negotiation, in the market or in politics, do not decide purely by calculation either. They play more cautiously when they can gain something and fight harder when they could lose something.
05
Applying it to companies
Situation
The researchers themselves drew parallels to business. There, too, there are artificial reference points: quarterly targets, budget targets, previous-year figures.
Link to the principle
If you narrowly miss a target, you feel you are in loss territory and fight hard. If you have reached it, you become cautious and leave opportunities on the table. With every target they set, leaders create a reference point. In doing so, they determine where their people become cautious and where they become combative.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Pay attention to which numbers count as par in your environment.
02
Keep in mind that even professionals give losses more weight than gains.
03
Check whether you play too cautiously when opportunities arise.
04
Set targets deliberately, because they create reference points.
05
Judge every stroke by its real value, not by how it feels.
Summary
Using 2.5 million putts, Devin G. Pope and Maurice E. Schweitzer showed that PGA professionals sink par putts more often than birdie putts of the same length. Par works as a reference point, a bogey as a loss. The bias persists despite experience, competition and high prize money. For strategy, this means: even professionals fight harder against losses than for gains.