In 1972, Richard Driscoll and colleagues report that couples grow closer when their parents interfere. The idea becomes famous. Later studies tend to find the opposite. The case shows how paradoxical logic can work, and that it does not apply automatically.
A golden dot presses against a mist-blue circle, a second dot presses back from the other side, and the circle grows larger instead of smaller. Then a broad line and a narrow line split apart; all the dots stream onto the broad one, it clogs, and a single golden dot glides ahead freely on the narrow one.
Principle #34
Paradoxical Logic: In conflict, the obvious often turns into its opposite because the other side reacts: pressure strengthens what it is meant to break, and the best route becomes a bad one as soon as everyone expects it.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Paradoxical Logic is seductive. It explains why well-intended measures fail, and it sounds clever. That is exactly why it pays to look at an example in which a paradoxical effect was claimed, celebrated and then not confirmed. It is a lesson for families and for anyone who works with pressure.
A barrier stands between two dots, a golden arc connects them, and pale rings drift apart – the Romeo and Juliet effect.
01
A study with a catchy name
Situation
In 1972, Richard Driscoll, Keith E. Davis and Milton E. Lipetz publish a study of 140 married and unmarried couples in the Journal of Personality and Social Psychology. They survey the couples twice, about six months to a year apart. The result: where parents interfered more, reported love also rose. At the same time, interference was associated with less trust and more criticism of the partner.
Link to the principle
This is the basic figure of paradoxical logic: the pressure meant to weaken a relationship strengthens it. The authors named the phenomenon after Shakespeare’s lovers, whose families are sworn enemies.
02
Why the idea seems so plausible
Situation
Psychology offers a mechanism that could explain the effect. In 1966, Jack W. Brehm described reactance: when people see their freedom threatened, the threatened option becomes more valuable to them. Bans make the forbidden attractive. Many parents know this from raising their children.
Link to the principle
Reactance is a form of paradoxical logic in everyday life. The other person is not a passive object but responds. If you don’t factor that response in, pressure will get you the opposite of what you want.
03
The test 40 years later
Situation
In 2014, a group led by the psychologist H. Colleen Sinclair tests the effect with 396 adults in relationships, roughly half of them married and half in a dating relationship. They are surveyed twice, about four months apart. The result: more parental approval predicted more love and commitment later on. More interference went along with less love and commitment among married participants; among the unmarried, there was no connection. Earlier studies, such as one by Malcolm Parks and colleagues in 1983, had already found little support for the effect.
Link to the principle
The paradoxical effect could not be replicated. Here, ordinary logic usually applies: disapproval from the people around a couple puts a strain on the relationship, while approval supports it. Paradoxical logic is not a law of nature. It occurs in certain situations, not in all of them.
04
When the logic flips and when it doesn’t
Situation
Edward N. Luttwak describes paradoxical logic for genuine conflicts, in which an opponent deliberately reacts to your actions. A family is usually not that kind of conflict. The couple doesn’t want to defeat the parents. They live with them, hear their objections and often take them seriously, even when they reject them.
Link to the principle
The more a situation resembles a fight, the more likely paradoxical logic is to apply. The more it is shaped by relationship and trust, the more likely ordinary logic is to apply. A brief ban can trigger defiance. Lasting disapproval wears people down.
05
What this means for parents
Situation
Many parents wonder whether they can criticize their children’s relationship without strengthening it. Recent research suggests that the people around a couple do have an influence, but more through approval and disapproval than through bans.
Link to the principle
If you know Paradoxical Logic, you refrain from laying down the law in ways that trigger reactance. If you know the research, you also refrain from the excuse that objecting will backfire anyway. Open, well-founded concerns within a solid relationship have a different effect than control.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
A ban can make the forbidden more attractive.
02
Paradoxical effects are possible, but not automatic.
03
Check catchy effects before you rely on them.
04
The more a situation resembles a fight, the more likely the logic is to flip.
05
Voicing concern is something different from exercising control.
Summary
In 1972, the Romeo and Juliet effect claimed that parental interference binds couples more closely together. The idea fit paradoxical logic and reactance theory and became famous. Later studies tended to find the opposite: approval supports, disapproval puts a strain on a relationship. The case shows that paradoxical logic applies above all in genuine conflicts and not automatically in relationships built on trust.
Richard Driscoll, Keith E. Davis, Milton E. Lipetz: Parental interference and romantic love: The Romeo & Juliet effect. In: Journal of Personality and Social Psychology 24 (1972), pp. 1–10.
H. Colleen Sinclair, K. B. Hood, B. L. Wright: Revisiting the Romeo and Juliet Effect: Reexamining the Links Between Social Network Opinions and Romantic Relationship Outcomes. In: Social Psychology (2014).
Jack W. Brehm: A Theory of Psychological Reactance. New York: Academic Press 1966.
Back to the basics
Read what lies behind Paradoxical Logic: with explanation, animation, video and research.