Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Sam Walton, Walmart and Relative Superiority

Example of the principleRelative Superiority (#8)

Business

Sam Walton, Walmart and Relative Superiority

In 1962 Sam Walton opens his first discount store in Rogers, Arkansas. Instead of taking on the big chains in the cities, he goes into small towns and builds his stores in dense clusters around his own warehouses. There he is stronger than any competitor, long before he is big overall.

In two rows, 10 teal dots face 20 mist-blue dots, and a balance beam above them tilts toward the larger row. The 10 draw together at one end; a golden circle of light shows 10 against 4 there, a small balance beam above the circle of light tips golden toward the other side, and the long row is rolled up from the flank.
Principle #8

Relative Superiority: You don’t have to be bigger overall, just stronger at the decisive point.

3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

In retail, size seems to be everything. Big chains buy more cheaply, advertise more widely and negotiate harder. In 1962 Sam Walton did not have that size. He created superiority for himself where the big players weren’t looking and extended it region by region. His story shows that Relative Superiority doesn’t apply only on battlefields.

Between large, pale city circles, small stores form dense clusters around a golden warehouse – like Sam Walton with Walmart in the small towns.
Between large, pale city circles, small stores form dense clusters around a golden warehouse – like Sam Walton with Walmart in the small towns.

A merchant from the provinces

Situation
Samuel Moore Walton, born in 1918 in Kingfisher, Oklahoma, opened a Ben Franklin variety store in Newport, Arkansas, in 1945. He later moved to Bentonville and ran a regional chain of such stores with his brother James. When Ben Franklin’s management rejected his idea of a discount store, he struck out on his own. In 1962 he opened the first Wal-Mart Discount City in Rogers.
Link to the principle
Against the big retail chains in the cities, Walton would have been outmatched across the board. If you are smaller overall, you have to find a place where you are bigger.

The small town as a playing field

Situation
Walton was convinced that not only big cities but small towns, too, could profitably support a discount store. The big chains focused mainly on the cities. In the small towns, Wal-Mart did not have to compete with them.
Link to the principle
Relative superiority begins with the choice of playing field. In a small town, Wal-Mart could be the biggest player, even while the company was still tiny nationwide. What matters is strength where the customer shops, not the figure on the balance sheet.

Stores in a circle around the warehouse

Situation
Walton built his stores in regional clusters. Each store was at most a day’s drive from a large warehouse. The warehouse bought in large quantities, and the company’s own trucks supplied the stores. Only when a region was densely covered did Wal-Mart move into the next.
Link to the principle
Here the second level of the principle comes into view. Instead of scattering stores over a large area, Walton clustered them. In every region, his supply chain was denser and cheaper than that of a competitor with only scattered stores there. The superiority was local, but there it was complete.

Growth region by region

Situation
In 1977 Wal-Mart had 190 stores; in 1985, about 800. Sam’s Club was added in 1983, and the first Supercenters followed in 1988. By 1990 Wal-Mart had overtaken Sears as the largest retailer in the United States. When Walton died on April 5, 1992, the company comprised 1,735 Wal-Marts, 212 Sam’s Clubs and 13 Supercenters, with 380,000 employees and annual sales of almost $50 billion.
Link to the principle
Relative superiority can be extended. Each region won became the base for the next. In the end, many local advantages added up to absolute size as well. But the path did not lead through a frontal attack; it led through many places where Walton was the stronger one in each case.

What the strength costs

Situation
The success changed the places Wal-Mart moved into. For decades, critics have accused the company of driving out small specialty stores and weakening town centers. Supporters point to lower prices for customers with little money.
Link to the principle
If you are superior in a place, you shape that place. Relative superiority is a tool, not a license. The question of how you use your local strength is part of strategy.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Look for a field on which you can be the biggest.
  2. Go where the big players aren’t looking.
  3. Concentrate your forces in one region before you take on the next.
  4. Make every place you win the base for the next one.
  5. Keep in mind the responsibility that comes with local strength.
Summary

In 1962 Sam Walton was small compared with the big retail chains. He avoided their cities, went into small towns and clustered his stores around his own warehouses. As a result, he was stronger than the competition in every region, even though he was smaller overall. Wal-Mart grew region by region until, by 1990, it was the largest retailer in the United States. The story shows relative superiority as a path to growth: first stronger locally, then big overall.

Sources
  • Sam Walton, John Huey: Made in America: My Story. New York: Doubleday 1992.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Relative Superiority: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Sam Walton, Walmart and Relative Superiority.