Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Stern, the Hitler Diaries and Speed

Example of the principleSpeed (#41)

Media

Stern, the Hitler Diaries and Speed

In April 1983, the German magazine Stern presents what are supposedly Adolf Hitler’s diaries as a sensation, without waiting for the expert report on the material. Eleven days later, the German Federal Archives establish that they are forged: an object lesson in how speed turns into haste.

A golden frame stands open, with three teal dots in front of it; while a line of dots runs out like sand, the sides of the frame slowly close in. One dot waits and fades, one draws a straight line through a small checking ring and reaches the frame before it closes, and the third skips past the ring and dissolves into mist-blue.
Principle #41

Speed: Speed uses windows of opportunity while they are open and spares everyone the exhaustion of a long struggle – as long as it does not turn into haste without scrutiny.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Sun Tzu praises speed. But before he writes about pace in his second chapter, he devotes the first chapter to calculation: whoever calculates thoroughly before the battle wins. Speed in acting presupposes care in checking. The case of the Hitler diaries shows what happens when the order is reversed and the fear of being too late crowds out the checking.

A stack of notebooks stands in the spotlight with a crack running through it, while the golden checking ring beside it remains untouched – as at Stern in 1983.
A stack of notebooks stands in the spotlight with a crack running through it, while the golden checking ring beside it remains untouched – as at Stern in 1983.

A secret purchase

Situation
Starting in February 1981, the publishing house Gruner + Jahr buys, through the Stern reporter Gerd Heidemann, volumes said to be Hitler’s diaries. Shortly before publication, there are 62 volumes for a total of around 9.3 million Deutsche Mark. The project runs under the code name “Green Vault.” At first, only a few people on the executive board know about it; the editors-in-chief are not let in on it until May 1981. The origin of the volumes is kept secret. Heidemann alone is in contact with the supplier.
Link to the principle
Secrecy was supposed to secure the lead. But it shut out precisely the people who could have checked. A fast coup that only succeeds if nobody asks questions is not speed but a risk.

Expert reports with false comparisons

Situation
Several handwriting experts and the Rhineland-Palatinate State Criminal Police Office confirm the handwriting. The historians Hugh Trevor-Roper and Gerhard Weinberg also initially consider the volumes genuine. The problem: the comparison samples against which the handwriting is measured themselves come from the forger’s workshop. A thorough examination of the material itself is still pending.
Link to the principle
There were checks, but only the fast ones. The slow, decisive examination of paper, binding and ink was not waited for. If you want to gain speed, you are tempted to skip the inconvenient check. Yet it was precisely this check that would have revealed the mistake.

A race with the competition

Situation
Stern is under pressure. The U.S. magazine Newsweek is negotiating for secondary rights, and the British Sunday Times is interested in excerpts. On April 25, 1983, Stern presents the volumes in Hamburg to around 200 reporters and 27 television crews. Experts voice doubts on the spot. Starting on April 28, the magazine prints excerpts without waiting for the report from the Federal Criminal Police Office.
Link to the principle
Here it was not the situation that set the pace but the fear that someone else would be faster. That is the typical path from speed to haste. Sun Tzu’s speed serves victory. The magazine’s hurry served only the deadline.

Eleven days

Situation
Starting on April 27, the Federal Institute for Materials Testing, the Federal Criminal Police Office and the Federal Archives examine the volumes. On May 2, all three reach the same result. On May 6, 1983, the Federal Archives declare publicly that the volumes are not genuine. Bindings, threads, paper and ink are for the most part not from the war years. The paper, for example, contains optical brighteners that did not come into use until around 1950. The content largely follows a printed collection of Hitler’s speeches, errors included. A day later, the forger is exposed as Konrad Kujau.
Link to the principle
The check that Stern skipped took only a few days. Slowness would have cost the magazine a few days. Haste cost it its credibility.

The consequences

Situation
The editors-in-chief, Peter Koch and Felix Schmidt, resign. On July 8, 1985, the Hamburg Regional Court sentences Konrad Kujau to four years and six months for fraud and forgery of documents, and Gerd Heidemann to four years and eight months for embezzlement. In Kujau’s case, the court treats the publisher’s share of responsibility as a mitigating factor. The case becomes a byword for one of the biggest press scandals in the history of the Federal Republic of Germany.
Link to the principle
Speed is a value as long as it serves the objective. Here the pace destroyed the objective itself: the biggest coup became the biggest embarrassment.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Calculate first, then act fast.
  2. Distrust any project that only succeeds if nobody checks.
  3. Never skip the inconvenient check to save time.
  4. Ask yourself whether the situation or your fear is setting the pace.
  5. Compare what a few days of waiting cost with what a mistake costs.
Summary

Stern wanted to be first with the sensation of the decade. Secrecy, expert reports based on forged comparison samples and the fear of the competition meant that publication came before the decisive examination of the material. Eleven days after the press conference, it was all over. The counterexample shows the limit of the principle: speed cuts waiting time, haste cuts scrutiny.

Sources
  • Sun Tzu: The Art of War. Translated by Lionel Giles. London: Luzac & Co. 1910 (Chapters 1 and 2).
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Speed: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Stern, the Hitler Diaries and Speed.