Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. VHS versus Betamax and the Square Law of Strength

Example of the principleSquare Law of Strength (#10)

BusinessMedia

VHS versus Betamax and the Square Law of Strength

Sony launches Betamax in 1975; JVC follows with VHS in 1976. JVC licenses its format to many manufacturers, while Sony keeps control. The combined strength of the VHS alliance grows faster than any single company, and Betamax loses despite its good technology.

Ten teal dots face five mist-blue dots; above both, the numbers grow into their squares, 100 and 25, and fine lines show how the five fall while only one or two of the 10 fade. Then a long mist-blue row faces a smaller teal group; two golden lines cut the row into parts, the teal dots mass in gold against one part after another, and finally all the dots close into a circle.
Principle #10

Square Law of Strength: If you concentrate your forces, you win not just a little more but disproportionately more – and if you spread them out, you lose disproportionately.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

The Square Law of Strength says that the effect of forces acting together grows faster than their numbers. In markets, this holds especially where customers need a common format. Every manufacturer that joins a format makes it more valuable for all the others. The battle of the video formats in the 1970s and 1980s is a well-known case study.

A golden cassette spans a dense web of many dots, while a smaller one stays alone in its ring – like VHS versus Betamax.
A golden cassette spans a dense web of many dots, while a smaller one stays alone in its ring – like VHS versus Betamax.

Sony gets there first

Situation
In 1974, Sony demonstrates its prototype to other manufacturers, expecting them to join. In late 1974 and early 1975, Sony also holds talks with Matsushita, JVC’s parent company. In 1975, Betamax goes on sale in Japan and the United States. Technically, it is regarded as a good system, with somewhat higher picture resolution than the later VHS.
Link to the principle
Sony has the edge in timing and quality. The company is betting that the better picture and the early start will be enough. That is a bet on its own strength as a single company.

JVC opens up its format

Situation
JVC introduces VHS in 1976. VHS cassettes hold two hours; the first Betamax cassettes hold one. JVC grants licenses to every manufacturer that wants to build machines. Matsushita opts for VHS, partly because the machines need fewer components and are cheaper to make. Hitachi, Sharp, Mitsubishi and Akai join; in the United States, RCA, Magnavox, Zenith and others sell VHS machines. For RCA, Matsushita even builds a machine with four hours of recording time. Sony also wins partners – Toshiba, Sanyo, NEC, Aiwa and Pioneer – but keeps tight control over manufacturing and the format.
Link to the principle
The VHS side pools the strength of many companies in one format. Each brings its own factories, distribution channels and customers. Their effects do not just add up; they reinforce one another: competition among the manufacturers lowers prices, lower prices bring in more buyers, and more buyers bring in more manufacturers.

The video stores have a say

Situation
In the late 1970s, the market for rental videos emerges. Film studios and video stores have to decide in which format to offer films. The more VHS machines there are in households, the more titles come out on VHS, and the more likely new customers are to buy a VHS machine. In 1980, VHS holds around 60% of the North American market; in 1987, around 90% of the U.S. market for videocassette recorders.
Link to the principle
This is where the disproportionate effect becomes visible. A small lead in machines turns into a bigger one in films, which in turn becomes an even bigger one in machines. The gap does not grow evenly; it accelerates until the smaller side can no longer keep up.

The end of Betamax

Situation
In 1988, Sony itself adds VHS machines to its range. Observers see this as an admission of defeat. Sony continues to make Betamax recorders until 2002, for an ever smaller circle of customers.
Link to the principle
Sony does not lose because Betamax was bad. Sony loses because, as a largely closed force, it took on a pooled one. Frederick William Lanchester put it this way for combat: numbers count squared, the quality of the individual unit only linearly. A better picture cannot make up for a superior alliance.

Limits of the comparison

Situation
The reasons for VHS’s victory are still debated today. Those cited include the longer recording time, the lower prices, the broad licensing and the larger selection of films. Some observers also point to individual content providers that favored VHS early on.
Link to the principle
Strictly speaking, the format war is a story of network effects, not of Lanchester’s law. But both share the same core: wherever size reinforces itself, the outcome is decided not by the best individual unit but by the largest united force.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Ask whether, in your field, the number of allies counts disproportionately.
  2. If so, share rights and benefits so that others will join you.
  3. Quality alone rarely wins against a larger, united alliance.
  4. Watch for the tipping point early; after that, it is almost impossible to catch up.
  5. Ask what your customers really need, not just what you think is better.
Summary

With Betamax, Sony was first to market and had the slightly better picture. JVC opened VHS to many manufacturers and in this way pooled the strength of an entire industry. More machines brought more films, and more films brought more machines. The lead grew disproportionately until, in 1988, Sony itself began offering VHS. The example shows the basic idea of the square law in the market: pooled strength beats better individual strength.

Sources
  • Frederick William Lanchester: Aircraft in Warfare: The Dawn of the Fourth Arm. London: Constable 1916.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Square Law of Strength: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: VHS versus Betamax and the Square Law of Strength.