China’s One-Child Policy and Unintended Consequences
In 1980, China limits most families to one child to slow population growth. The goal is achieved, but the policy leaves behind millions of surplus men and a society that is growing old faster than it is growing rich.
A gold dot nudges a row of small circles that a line steers toward a gold ring; at the same time, mist-blue side rows run off in other directions, speed up and topple a frame at the edge. In the second run, an arc of light reveals the whole field, two circles disappear, a teal crossbar slows the side rows, and only the gold line reaches its goal.
Principle #86
Unintended Consequences: Every targeted action intervenes in a system that responds; if you think only of the intended effect, you will be surprised by the side effects.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Hardly any political measure has reached as deeply into family life as China’s one-child policy. It had a clear goal and was enforced with great harshness. Precisely for that reason, it is a case of Unintended Consequences as the sociologist Robert K. Merton described them in 1936: purposive action produces consequences that no one wanted. Some of them are stronger and longer-lasting than the intended effect.
Four dots rest on two, two on one – an upside-down triangle weighs on a single gold dot – like China’s one-child policy.
01
The fear of growth
Situation
At the end of the 1970s, almost a billion people live in China. The leadership under Deng Xiaoping wants to modernize the country and fears that population growth will eat up all economic progress. Projections by experts around the missile engineer Song Jian paint a bleak picture. After initial regulations in 1979, the government introduces the one-child policy nationwide in 1980.
Link to the principle
The calculation is simple: fewer children, less growth, more prosperity per head. Merton names the overriding interest in the immediate goal as one cause of unintended consequences. If you look at only one number, you overlook how families, culture and the economy react to the intervention.
02
Incentives and coercion
Situation
Families who comply with the rule receive financial benefits and better career opportunities. Those who resist face penalties. Millions of people experience harsh enforcement, up to and including forced sterilizations and forced abortions. Over the years, exceptions are made, for example for parts of the rural population and for ethnic minorities.
Link to the principle
The harshness of the enforcement shows how seriously the goal is taken. It also shows that the consequences are not just statistics. Behind every number are families whose lives the policy changes. Unintended consequences are often human costs that did not appear in the original calculation.
03
Millions of missing women
Situation
In many Chinese families, a son is traditionally seen as provision for old age and as the one who carries on the family line. If only one child is allowed, it should be a son. Sex-selective abortions increase, and girls are abandoned or given to orphanages. In 2016, according to official figures, China has about 33.6 million more men than women.
Link to the principle
This is a consequence that arises from the interplay of rule and culture. Merton names basic values as a further cause: people act on their convictions even when that undermines the intention of a measure. The planners wanted fewer children. They got fewer girls.
04
A society ages too fast
Situation
Fewer births mean that after a few decades there are fewer young workers and many old people. In many families, a single child later has to support two parents and four grandparents. The population is aging fast, and the number of working people is shrinking.
Link to the principle
In principle, this consequence was foreseeable; it simply lay far in the future. Many unintended consequences are not surprises in the strict sense. They are overlooked because they arrive later than the success by which you are judged.
05
The change of course that doesn’t take hold
Situation
At the end of 2015, the government announces the end of the one-child rule. Starting in 2016, two children are allowed, and starting in 2021, three. But the birth rate stays low. Small families have become the norm, and housing and education are expensive. In 2022, China’s population shrinks for the first time in decades.
Link to the principle
A policy can be lifted; its consequences cannot. What shaped the behavior of families for decades continues to have an effect long after the rule has disappeared. If you intervene in a system, you often change it permanently.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Ask not only whether your measure achieves its goal but what else it sets off.
02
Be prepared for people to react according to their values, not according to your plan.
03
Look beyond the period in which your success is measured.
04
Human costs belong in the calculation before you act.
05
Some interventions you can reverse; their consequences you cannot.
Summary
Starting in 1980, China’s one-child policy was meant to slow population growth, and it did. At the same time, combined with the preference for sons, it led to a large surplus of men and made society age rapidly. When the government changed course, the birth rate stayed low. The example shows Robert K. Merton’s insight: targeted interventions produce consequences that can be stronger and more lasting than the intended effect.