Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Principles
  3. Unintended Consequences
86Principle · Group 10

Unintended Consequences

Law of unintended consequences

“Every targeted action intervenes in a system that responds; if you think only of the intended effect, you will be surprised by the side effects.”

Every action you take to pursue a goal sets off more than that goal.

A gold dot nudges a row of small circles that a line steers toward a gold ring; at the same time, mist-blue side rows run off in other directions, speed up and topple a frame at the edge. In the second run, an arc of light reveals the whole field, two circles disappear, a teal crossbar slows the side rows, and only the gold line reaches its goal.
In short

Every targeted action intervenes in a system that responds; if you think only of the intended effect, you will be surprised by the side effects.

What it’s about: Every action you take to pursue a goal sets off more than that goal. People and systems react: they adapt, sidestep or use a rule differently from how you meant it. Some side effects are harmless. Some outweigh the intended effect or reverse it.

In depth

The principle in detail

Three steps through the principle: grasp it, place it, put it to work. Open each topic on its own.

The core messageCore statement and 3 clarifications
In essence

Every targeted action meets people and systems that react. The side effects are part of the action.

It does not say
That you are better off doing nothing. Inaction has consequences too, and you are responsible for them as well.
It does not say
That every reform achieves the opposite of what it intends. Anyone who claims that across the board is using the principle as a brake.
It also says
Side effects can be good. Adam Smith described how self-interested action can unintentionally serve the common good.
The explanationHow the principle works and what matters

Unintended consequences arrive by three routes: as a surprise no one thought of, as a reversal of the purpose, or as a long-term effect that seemed too far off to take seriously. You can estimate them beforehand and measure them afterward.

The question

What does your next step set off besides what you want?

The signs3 signs when you heed it · 3 when you overlook it
When you heed it
  • Before introducing a new rule, you ask how the people affected will use it.
  • Besides the target figure, you watch what happens alongside it.
  • You listen to critics before you start.
When you overlook it
  • A key figure rises while the thing it stands for gets worse.
  • When a measure doesn’t work, you respond by getting tougher.
  • Problems crop up in areas no one had thought of.
The backgroundFrom Robert K. Merton’s essay “The Unanticipated Consequences of Purposive Social Action” (1936).
  1. 1936
    OriginRobert K. Merton

    The Unanticipated Consequences of Purposive Social Action

  2. 1991
    SupplementedAlbert O. Hirschman

    The Rhetoric of Reaction

  3. 2001
    SupplementedHorst Siebert

    Der Kobra-Effekt

  4. Tradition T7
    TraditionPsychology and Decision-Making

    Daniel Kahneman, Robert B. Cialdini

    See the tradition on the Origin page
Read more: the full background

From Robert K. Merton’s essay “The Unanticipated Consequences of Purposive Social Action” (1936). Supplemented by Albert O. Hirschman’s “The Rhetoric of Reaction” (1991) and Horst Siebert’s “Der Kobra-Effekt” (“The Cobra Effect,” 2001).

The research4 sources: 2 theories, 1 classic, 1 review · 1936–2001 · with limitations of the research
4 sources1936–2001 period2 theories1 classic1 review
Strength of evidence
  1. weak
  2. moderate
  3. strong

The causes of unintended consequences have been described in classic works and are documented by many cases; how often side effects outweigh the intended effect has not been measured.

  1. 1936
    Classic
    Robert K. Merton

    “The Unanticipated Consequences of Purposive Social Action”: five causes of purposive action having consequences that no one foresaw.

  2. 1979
    Theory
    Donald T. Campbell

    “Assessing the Impact of Planned Social Change”: a key figure used for social decisions comes under pressure and distorts what it is meant to measure.

  3. 1991
    Theory
    Albert O. Hirschman

    “The Rhetoric of Reaction”: the claim that a reform makes the ill worse is one of three recurring arguments against change.

  4. 2001
    Review
    Horst Siebert

    “Der Kobra-Effekt” (“The Cobra Effect,” in German): wrong turns in economic policy in which an incentive brings about the opposite of what was intended.

Where the research reaches its limits
  • The principle can be misused: Albert O. Hirschman describes how the appeal to perverse effects has been used for centuries against necessary change.
  • Not every side effect is bad, and not every one is foreseeable.
  • If you do nothing for fear of the consequences, you are responsible for consequences too.
  • The story of the bounty for dead cobras in India, after which Horst Siebert named the effect, is not historically established.
  • The claim that side effects often outweigh the intended effect comes from case histories; it is not a measured frequency.
Read more: what research shows

In 1936, Robert K. Merton asked why purposive action so often produces results that no one wanted. He named five causes: ignorance, error, the overriding interest in the immediate result, basic values that prescribe an action, and predictions that themselves change behavior. In 1979, Donald T. Campbell described a common special case: the more a key figure is used for decisions, the more likely it is to be corrupted, and the more it distorts the processes it is meant to monitor. Charles Goodhart had observed something similar for monetary policy. In 1991, Albert O. Hirschman showed the flip side: pointing to perverse effects is an old argument against reform. The evidence for the principle consists mainly of case histories and conceptual work, with hardly any measurement.

The related principles18 Friction · 61 Security Dilemma · 81 Path Dependence · 88 Scenario Thinking

88 Scenario Thinking provides the tool for playing through consequences in advance

81 Path Dependence shows how early decisions have long-lasting effects

61 Security Dilemma describes the special case in which protection increases the threat

With 18 Friction, the principle shares the insight that much in reality turns out differently than on paper

Read more: the full text

88 Scenario Thinking provides the tool for playing through consequences in advance; 81 Path Dependence shows how early decisions have long-lasting effects, and 61 Security Dilemma describes the special case in which protection increases the threat. With 18 Friction, the principle shares the insight that much in reality turns out differently than on paper.

The action steps5 action steps: Before any major measure, ask who is affected and how each of them will react.
  1. Before any major measure, ask who is affected and how each of them will react. Think through at least three reactions.
  2. Have someone who was not involved in the plan read the new rule and tell you how they would exploit it to their advantage.

  3. Besides the target figure, measure two or three figures that could suffer from it, such as quality, satisfaction or sick leave.

  4. Set a date on which you will look for side effects, including beyond your own area of responsibility.

  5. If a measure isn’t working, don’t increase the dose first. Check whether it has set off something that is working against it.
The reflection questions3 questions: Which key figure in your area is being met while the thing behind it suffers?
  1. Which key figure in your area is being met while the thing behind it suffers?
  2. Which people affected by your next decision have you not yet asked?
  3. Which measure have you tightened instead of asking why it isn’t working?

Take your time with one question. Write down your answer – or talk it over with someone you trust.

To finish
The picture to rememberThe animation once more, with an explanation
  1. A gold dot nudges a row of small circles that a line steers toward a gold ring
  2. At the same time, mist-blue side rows run off in other directions, speed up and topple a frame at the edge
  3. In the second run, an arc of light reveals the whole field, two circles disappear, a teal crossbar slows the side rows, and only the gold line reaches its goal
Strategy Check

What else will your next step set off?

Get your profile across all 12 groups in about 10 to 15 minutes.

Start the Strategy Check
In context

Group 10: Psychology and the Irrational

Guiding question: Which forces in the mind steer decisions?

Stage 2 of 5: Understand the situation

Where the 92 principles come from: eight traditions of strategy, from classical war theory to dealing with uncertainty.

More about the origin

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

FAQ

Questions about Unintended Consequences

What does the principle of Unintended Consequences say?

Besides the intended effect, every purposive action produces other effects that no one planned. Some of them are stronger than the intended effect or reverse it.

Where does the principle of Unintended Consequences come from?

The sociologist Robert K. Merton described it in the American Sociological Review in 1936 and named five causes. The idea goes back to Adam Smith’s invisible hand.

What are some examples of unintended consequences?

China’s one-child policy led to a surplus of men and an aging population, Prohibition strengthened organized crime, and rabbits brought to Australia for hunting became a plague across the land.

How well is Unintended Consequences supported by research?

Evidence: moderate – the causes of unintended consequences have been described in classic works and are documented by many cases; how often side effects outweigh the intended effect has not been measured.

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Unintended Consequences.