David Cameron, the Brexit Referendum and the Paradoxical Trinity
In 2013, David Cameron promises a referendum on EU membership to placate his party. He is counting on winning clearly with persuasiveness and economic arguments. On June 23, 2016, a narrow majority votes to leave, and Cameron announces his resignation. This counterexample shows what happens when you underestimate passion.
Three dots in teal and mist-blue form the corners of a triangle; in the middle, a golden circle hangs from a fine line and swings, drawn now toward one corner, now toward another, its path never tracing the same line twice. Then one corner fades, a straight line shows the planned route, and the golden circle still veers off, because the faded corner keeps pulling.
Principle #20
Paradoxical Trinity: Every conflict is shaped at once by passion, chance and reason, and if you overlook one of these three forces, you miscalculate.
3 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents
Carl von Clausewitz assigned the three forces of his paradoxical trinity to three bearers: passion mainly to the people, chance mainly to the commander and his army, and reason mainly to the government. A government that accounts only for reason overlooks the other two. The Brexit referendum is an instructive example of this from recent politics.
Two columns of dots of almost equal height, the right one rising two golden rows higher, the hoped-for height dashed – as in the Brexit referendum.
01
A promise to his own party
Situation
In January 2013, Prime Minister David Cameron gives a speech at the London headquarters of the news agency Bloomberg. He announces that he will renegotiate the terms of Britain’s EU membership and then hold a referendum on remaining or leaving, provided his Conservative Party wins the next election outright. The move is seen as a concession to the Euroskeptic wing of his party.
Link to the principle
This is a decision of reason, more precisely a tactical calculation. Cameron wants to end a conflict within his party. According to a report in the Gulf Times, many in Westminster believed he never expected to actually have to hold the referendum.
02
An unexpected victory
Situation
In the general election of May 2015, the Conservatives surprisingly win a majority of their own. With that, the promise becomes reality. In February 2016, Cameron presents the result of his renegotiation. Among other things, it includes limits on certain welfare benefits for newly arrived EU citizens and the assurance that Britain does not have to take part in an “ever closer union.”
Link to the principle
This shows the play of probabilities. An election victory that strengthens Cameron also puts him in the very situation he presumably wanted to avoid. A plan built on a certain probability becomes dangerous when the unlikely outcome occurs.
03
Numbers versus feelings
Situation
The campaign to remain argues mainly with the economic damage of leaving. The other side focuses on national self-determination, control of immigration and the money that flows to the EU. Prominent Conservatives such as London Mayor Boris Johnson and Justice Secretary Michael Gove, until then one of Cameron’s most loyal allies, join the Leave camp.
Link to the principle
One side appeals mainly to reason, the other mainly to feelings of identity, pride and control. Cameron was counting on winning with the same persuasiveness that had already brought him two election victories. He underestimated how strongly voters’ passion can work against a purely economic argument.
04
Events no one controls
Situation
For months, the polls are close and contradictory. Sometimes Remain is ahead, sometimes Leave. A week before the vote, the Labour MP Jo Cox is murdered, and the campaigns are suspended until June 19. Even a poll from voting day, published after the polling stations closed, shows Remain narrowly ahead.
Link to the principle
A referendum is not a process you can plan. Events, moods and small shifts can tip the result. If you call such a vote, you hand part of the control over to chance. You can do that deliberately. But you should not do it on the assumption that the outcome is certain.
05
The result
Situation
On June 23, 2016, 51.89% vote to leave and 48.11% to remain. Turnout is 72.21%. A few hours later, Cameron announces his resignation. In July, Theresa May becomes prime minister.
Link to the principle
The result is close. That alone shows how large a part passion and chance played. A plan that rested on reason alone ended up facing a movement that it had not set off and could not steer.
Key takeaways
Key lessons
01
Don’t resolve a conflict with a promise whose consequences you don’t want to bear.
02
Check what happens if the unlikely outcome occurs.
03
Arguments alone do not win against strong feelings.
04
If you call an open vote, you hand control over to chance.
05
Ask yourself which of the three forces you are overlooking right now.
Summary
David Cameron called the Brexit referendum out of tactical calculation and ran the campaign mainly on economic arguments. An unexpected election victory, close polls and the passion of many voters turned the calculation into a defeat. This counterexample shows Carl von Clausewitz’s paradoxical trinity: if you account only for reason, you miscalculate.