Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Hernán Cortés, the Ships of Veracruz and Death Ground

Example of the principleDeath Ground (#85)

Government & Politics

Hernán Cortés, the Ships of Veracruz and Death Ground

In the summer of 1519, on Mexico’s Gulf Coast, Hernán Cortés has almost all of his ships destroyed. His men are left with no way back to Cuba, only the way forward. That is exactly what he wants.

Many small dots stand at a fork; one line leads back to an arch at the bottom edge, one forward onto a rise, and the dots split into teal and mist-blue, some of them drifting back. Then the arch fades, all the dots turn gold and move forward together; in the final image, a ring closes around a dark circle that grows until a gap opens in the ring and it slips out.
Principle #85

Death Ground: If you have no way back, you release strengths that would otherwise stay hidden; that is why it can be wise to cut off your own retreat deliberately – and unwise to take it away from an opponent.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

If you “burn your ships,” you make a decision that can no longer be reversed. The expression is usually associated with Hernán Cortés. Similar tales are told about Agathocles of Syracuse and about the general Tariq ibn Ziyad. Sun Tzu described the idea long before: an army that cannot flee fights with all its strength. He calls this situation death ground. The case of Cortés shows how the principle of Death Ground works. It also shows how a myth reshapes the facts and what price others paid for this resolve.

Off the coast, only dashed outlines of ships remain; on land, a row of dots climbs toward a golden goal – like Cortés at Veracruz.
Off the coast, only dashed outlines of ships remain; on land, a row of dots climbs toward a golden goal – like Cortés at Veracruz.

An order that is revoked

Situation
In 1518, Diego Velázquez de Cuéllar, the Spanish governor of Cuba, fits out an expedition to the coast of what is now Mexico and gives the command to Hernán Cortés. Shortly before departure, Velázquez begins to doubt his loyalty and revokes the order. Cortés sets sail anyway in February 1519, with 11 ships and a few hundred men. The figures for the size of the force vary from source to source.
Link to the principle
The departure itself is already a step into the unknown. Cortés is acting without a valid order. If he returns without success, he faces punishment. For him personally, then, there is hardly any way back left. For many of his men, that is not yet the case. They could return to Cuba, and some of them want to.

A town as a way out of the order

Situation
After sailing along the coast of Yucatán, the expedition lands on the Gulf Coast. There, Cortés has the town of Villa Rica de la Vera Cruz founded. Its newly appointed council names him captain general, answerable directly to the Spanish Crown. A ship sails to Spain with gold and reports for Charles V.
Link to the principle
With this step, Cortés breaks away from Velázquez. Only a success that the king recognizes can justify his actions after the fact. The bridge to the governor has thus been burned politically before a single ship has been destroyed.

The conspiracy

Situation
Some of the men remain loyal to Velázquez. According to the account of Bernal Díaz del Castillo, who took part in the expedition, several of them plan to seize a ship and sail to Cuba to warn the governor. Cortés uncovers the plot and has two of those involved executed.
Link to the principle
As long as ships lie off the coast, there is an alternative to the march inland. Every alternative splits the group into those who want to press on and those who want to go back. Sun Tzu describes exactly this problem: troops stationed close to home scatter easily. Only when there is no way back do many individuals become one unit.

The ships run aground

Situation
In the summer of 1519, Cortés has his remaining ships run onto the beach and made unusable. According to Bernal Díaz, the pilots had first declared the ships unseaworthy. Rigging, anchors and iron are salvaged, and the sailors reinforce the troops. The earliest accounts speak of the ships being run aground. Only later tellings turn this into the burning of the fleet.
Link to the principle
Cortés turns an open question into a closed one. No one has to decide anymore whether to stay. The strength that would otherwise flow into quarreling and doubt goes into the march. At the same time, he gains the sailors as additional fighters. Here death ground is not a kind of terrain but a situation that a leader creates deliberately.

What the myth leaves out

Situation
In August 1519, Cortés sets out for Tenochtitlan. The Spaniards’ success does not rest on their resolve alone. What proves decisive are alliances with Indigenous peoples, above all with Tlaxcala, who are fighting against the rule of the Mexica, and later the diseases the Spaniards bring with them. The conquest is accompanied by great violence. In August 1521, Tenochtitlan falls.
Link to the principle
Death ground explains why a small force holds together. It does not explain why it wins. If you tell the story only as a lesson in courage, you overlook the allies, the circumstances and the victims. The principle describes an effect on your own people. It does not justify the goal.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. An open way back splits a group into the hesitant and the resolute.
  2. You can create clarity by deliberately closing off an alternative.
  3. Close the way back only once you have soberly examined the situation.
  4. Resolve is no substitute for allies or for good reasons.
  5. Test your goal before you burn your bridges; afterward it is too late.
Summary

In 1519, Hernán Cortés ran his ships aground on the coast at Veracruz. In doing so, he took away the doubters’ chance to return to Cuba and bound all their strength to the way inland. This is Sun Tzu’s death ground, brought about deliberately. The later myth of the burning of the ships obscures the fact that the Spaniards’ success rested above all on alliances and circumstances and was bought with great violence.

Sources
  • Bernal Díaz del Castillo: Historia verdadera de la conquista de la Nueva España. Written around 1568, first printed in Madrid in 1632.
  • Hernán Cortés: Cartas de relación (reports to Charles V, 1519–1526).
  • Hugh Thomas: Conquest: Montezuma, Cortés, and the Fall of Old Mexico. New York: Simon & Schuster 1993.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind Death Ground: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Hernán Cortés, the Ships of Veracruz and Death Ground.