Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. James Brussel, the Mad Bomber and the Principle “Become the Enemy”

Example of the principleBecome the Enemy (#84)

Government & PoliticsEducation

James Brussel, the Mad Bomber and the Principle “Become the Enemy”

For 16 years, an unknown man plants bombs in New York, and the police find no trail. In 1956, the psychiatrist James A. Brussel reads the perpetrator’s letters, gets inside his head and describes a man who in many respects resembles George Metesky, the man later caught.

A teal dot stands at the edge of a grid of lines, and short lines of thought run from it across the grid. It travels in an arc to the opposite side, the grid turns with it, and from this view a gold line lights up, the other side’s planned move; back in its own place, it sets a small circle so that the gold line runs into nothing.
Principle #84

Become the Enemy: If you see the situation through your opponent’s eyes – their needs, fears and habits – you recognize their next move before they make it.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

The Japanese sword master Miyamoto Musashi advised putting yourself so deeply in your opponent’s place that you think from their point of view – the principle “Become the Enemy.” What he meant for single combat became a method of police work centuries later. One of the first well-known cases is that of New York’s “Mad Bomber.” It shows what the principle can achieve, and also where its limits lie.

From stacked letters, lines run across a city grid full of bomb sites to a golden house – like James Brussel, who read the Mad Bomber’s mind.
From stacked letters, lines run across a city grid full of bomb sites to a golden house – like James Brussel, who read the Mad Bomber’s mind.

An opponent without a face

Situation
On November 16, 1940, a bomb was found at a building of the utility company Consolidated Edison. It did not explode. With it was a note that railed against the company. After the attack on Pearl Harbor, the perpetrator announced in a letter that he would take a break during the war. Starting in 1951, he planted bombs again, including in Grand Central Station and in a phone booth at the New York Public Library. By 1956, according to current figures, there had been at least 33, of which 22 exploded. Fifteen people were injured; no one was killed.
Link to the principle
The police had clues but no picture. They looked for fingerprints and witnesses. What was missing was an understanding of who does something like this and why. Only if you understand an opponent’s motives can you predict where he will turn up.

The psychiatrist reads the letters

Situation
In 1956, the New York police brought in the psychiatrist James A. Brussel. He met with Inspector Howard E. Finney, the head of the crime lab, and studied the letters, the bomb sites and the photos. He described a man between 40 and 50, of Slavic descent and Catholic, with a deep grudge against Consolidated Edison. The man, he said, was probably paranoid and unmarried and perhaps lived with an older female relative, probably in Connecticut.
Link to the principle
Brussel did not ask where the next bomb might be but how the perpetrator saw the world. Hatred of a single company pointed to a personal grievance. The formal, old-fashioned style of the letters pointed to a man who lived a withdrawn life and valued order. In this way, a person emerged from the clues.

The suit

Situation
What became famous above all was a prediction that Brussel later described in his book: when they found the man, he would be wearing a double-breasted suit, buttoned. The idea behind it: a meticulous person who cares about correctness shows it in his clothing too. The claim that he made the prediction in this form and that it proved true at the arrest rests mainly on Brussel’s own account.
Link to the principle
This prediction is more anecdote than method. But it shows the approach: Brussel did not try to collect data but to understand the character so well that behavior could be derived from it. That is the core of the principle. If you know the character, you can predict even small details.

Getting the perpetrator to talk

Situation
The New York Journal-American newspaper published open letters to the bomber, urging him to turn himself in and state his grievances. The perpetrator replied. In one letter, he gave the date of his workplace accident, September 5, 1931. On January 18, 1957, the Con Edison employee Alice Kelly found in old files the case of a former worker who had been injured in that accident and had demanded compensation in vain. On January 21, 1957, George Metesky was arrested at his home in Waterbury, Connecticut. He lived with two unmarried sisters.
Link to the principle
The decisive clue came not from the profile alone but from understanding the perpetrator’s need to be heard. If you see yourself as the victim of an injustice, you want to explain that injustice. The newspaper gave him the stage, and he gave himself away. This is the principle in its most effective form: you use the opponent’s motives so that he takes the next step himself.

Hits and misses

Situation
Metesky was 53 years old, born in Waterbury, the son of Lithuanian immigrants, and he was diagnosed as a paranoid schizophrenic. Much of the profile fit, but not all of it: Brussel had guessed an age of 40 to 50 and Slavic descent. Critics such as the journalist Malcolm Gladwell later objected that the hits seem bigger in hindsight than they were, and that it was above all the search through the files that led to success.
Link to the principle
Putting yourself in the opponent’s place does not replace facts. It gives the search a direction. The art lies in combining both: the picture of the opponent and the sober check of whether it is accurate.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Don’t just ask what the other person does; ask what drives them.
  2. Read a person’s language; it reveals how they think.
  3. Use the other person’s need to be heard.
  4. Test your picture of the other person against facts.
  5. Have the courage to turn your understanding into a concrete prediction.
Summary

Between 1940 and 1956, an unknown man planted at least 33 bombs in New York. The psychiatrist James A. Brussel got inside the perpetrator’s head and described an aggrieved, unmarried man who probably lived in Connecticut. A newspaper’s open letters got the perpetrator to give himself away, and an employee found his file. George Metesky matched the profile in many respects. The case shows the power of the principle and at the same time that it needs facts.

Sources
  • James A. Brussel: Casebook of a Crime Psychiatrist. New York: Bernard Geis 1968.
  • Malcolm Gladwell: Dangerous Minds. In: The New Yorker, November 12, 2007.
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the principle “Become the Enemy”: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: James Brussel, the Mad Bomber and the Principle “Become the Enemy”.