Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Examples
  3. Lee Soo-man, SM Entertainment and the Value Chain

Example of the principleValue Chain (#71)

Arts, Entertainment & Sports

Lee Soo-man, SM Entertainment and the Value Chain

In June 2011, in Paris, Lee Soo-man, the founder of SM Entertainment, explains his “culture technology.” It describes how casting, years of training, production and partners abroad mesh together. The advantage lies not in any single star but in the chain that produces stars.

Five teal circles stand in a row with four mist-blue lines below them as supports; a gold dot travels from left to right and grows a little at each circle. At the turning point, fine gold lines stretch between the circles, a dot runs back on an arc from the last circle to the first, and in the final image the dot travels twice as fast and arrives clearly larger.
Principle #71

Value Chain: Your advantage lies not in the company as a whole but in individual activities and in how well they fit together.

4 min read5 sectionsSituationLink to the principle
Contents

Pop music often looks like a matter of talent and luck. The South Korean music industry has turned it into a system. SM Entertainment, founded by Lee Soo-man in 1989 as SM Studio and operating under its current name since 1995, is one of the companies that shaped this system. In 2023, after a dispute over control of the company, Lee sold a large part of his shares and withdrew from SM. SM is a good illustration of what Michael E. Porter means by the Value Chain: the lead arises in individual activities and in how they fit together.

Many dots fall into a funnel, a few pass through a long tube, and at the end a gold dot emerges – as with SM Entertainment.
Many dots fall into a funnel, a few pass through a long tube, and at the end a gold dot emerges – as with SM Entertainment.

A speech in Paris

Situation
On June 11, 2011, according to the Korea Times, Lee Soo-man speaks in Paris at a conference of authors and publishers, on the sidelines of the “SM Town in Paris” concerts. There he explains the concept of culture technology, which he says he developed in the mid-1990s to break into other Asian markets. Culture technology covers the entire path to stardom, from the music to the makeup, and follows a systematic process.
Link to the principle
Lee describes his business not as a collection of hits but as a sequence of steps. That is the value chain perspective. If you break your work down in this way, you can shape and improve each step deliberately.

Casting and training

Situation
SM looks for future pop stars in worldwide auditions. After selection, according to the Korea Times, the company simulates how the candidates’ voices and appearance might change over the next three to seven years. Then they go through the company’s in-house training system.
Link to the principle
This is a link in the chain that others can hardly copy. A Western record label usually signs artists who are already finished products. SM, by contrast, invests years in training before a single song is released. This step is costly, but it creates exactly the reliability on which all the later steps build.

Songs from around the world

Situation
Many hits are created with songwriters from outside Korea. For the group Girls’ Generation, the Korea Times names the English songwriter Alex James for the songs “Run Devil Run” and “Hoot,” and the European team Design Music for “Tell Me Your Wish.”
Link to the principle
Not every link has to be in-house. SM buys in songs where they fit best and combines them with its own training, its own choreography and its own performance. Porter counts procurement among the support activities. It, too, can be an advantage if it is well linked to the rest.

Three stages abroad

Situation
Lee describes three stages. First, a cultural product is exported. Then the presence in the target country grows through partnerships with local companies and singers. Finally, joint ventures emerge that share the know-how of culture technology. In Lee’s words, “‘Made by’ is more important than ‘Made in’”: a star can come from another country and still be created with SM’s system.
Link to the principle
In the end, the core of the advantage is not the individual product but the knowledge of how the chain works. If you have this knowledge, you can transfer the chain to other countries. The value chain itself becomes the product.

The people in the chain

Situation
The training system of the Korean music industry is repeatedly criticized for long and strict contracts. In 2009, three of the five members of the SM group TVXQ sued over their 13-year contract, which they considered too long and unfair. In 2010, Korea’s antitrust regulator, the Fair Trade Commission, objected to SM’s contract terms, and contract durations were shortened. In 2012, SM and the three singers agreed to terminate all contracts.
Link to the principle
Porter counts human resource management among the support activities. If it overburdens people, it endangers the whole chain. A system that produces artists is only as strong as the trust of the people who carry it.
Key takeaways

Key lessons

  1. Describe your work as a sequence of steps, not as a result.
  2. Invest in the link that others cannot quickly copy.
  3. Buy in what others do better, and link it well to your core.
  4. Your knowledge of the chain can be worth more than any single product.
  5. Don’t forget the people who carry the chain.
Summary

At SM Entertainment, Lee Soo-man built a system in which casting, training, production and partnerships abroad mesh closely. He calls it culture technology. The example shows how an advantage arises from a whole chain of activities, and it shows at the same time that this chain holds only if the people in it are treated fairly.

Sources
  • Michael E. Porter: Competitive Advantage: Creating and Sustaining Superior Performance. New York: Free Press 1985.
  • Wikipedia: SM Entertainment Link
Back to the basics

Read what lies behind the Value Chain: with explanation, animation, video and research.

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Lee Soo-man, SM Entertainment and the Value Chain.