Strategy
Blog
  1. Home
  2. Principles
  3. Escalation Ladder
68Principle · Group 8

Escalation Ladder

Herman Kahn’s escalation ladder

“If you know the rungs of a conflict and are credibly superior on the next one, you determine how far the dispute goes.”

Conflicts unfold in stages: a stern word, a formal warning, a tangible consequence, an open break.

A ladder of six teal lines stands in the frame, with a gold threshold glowing between two pairs of rungs. Two dots climb higher in turn, growing smaller and paler, until one merely directs a beam at the next rung, where its outline appears large, and the other glides one rung down.
In short

If you know the rungs of a conflict and are credibly superior on the next one, you determine how far the dispute goes.

What it’s about: Conflicts unfold in stages: a stern word, a formal warning, a tangible consequence, an open break. Between some of these stages lie thresholds at which the nature of the dispute changes. Words turn into deeds, a private matter becomes a public one, a factual issue becomes a personal attack. Whoever crosses such a threshold sends a message nobody can miss.

In depth

The principle in detail

Three steps through the principle: grasp it, place it, put it to work. Open each topic on its own.

The core messageCore statement and 3 clarifications
In essence

If you know the rungs of a conflict, you can judge what a step means and how the other side is likely to react.

It does not say
That you should make threats. The model is above all a tool for understanding and limiting conflict.
It does not say
That conflicts climb in an orderly way, rung by rung. Often they jump.
It also says
A ladder holds only if the next rung is actually possible and the will to take it is evident.
The explanationThe principle works because the parties to a conflict think ahead.

The principle works because the parties to a conflict think ahead. If you know that the other side is stronger on the next rung, you think twice about your next step.

The question

Do you know the next rung of your conflict, and do you also know the way back down?

The signs3 signs when you heed it · 3 when you overlook it
When you heed it
  • Your people know the rungs before a dispute begins, and you stick to them yourself.
  • Before every sharper step, you ask what it tells the other side.
  • For every conflict, you know a way back.
When you overlook it
  • You skip the lower rungs and go straight to the whole group.
  • You reflexively escalate by one rung.
  • You threaten consequences you never follow through on and lose your credibility as a result.
The backgroundFrom Herman Kahn’s work “On Escalation: Metaphors and Scenarios” (1965). · T5 Game Theory, Negotiation and Conflict
  1. 1965
    OriginHerman Kahn

    On Escalation: Metaphors and Scenarios

  2. 1966
    SupplementedThomas C. Schelling

    Arms and Influence

  3. 1980
    SupplementedFriedrich Glasl

    Konfliktmanagement

  4. Tradition T5
    TraditionGame Theory, Negotiation and Conflict

    Thomas C. Schelling, Robert Axelrod, Herman Kahn, Roger Fisher and William Ury

    See the tradition on the Origin page
Read more: the full background

From Herman Kahn’s work “On Escalation: Metaphors and Scenarios” (1965). Supplemented by Thomas C. Schelling’s “Arms and Influence” (1966) and Friedrich Glasl’s “Konfliktmanagement” (1980).

The research3 sources: 3 theories · 1965–1980 · with limitations of the research
3 sources1965–1980 period3 theories
Strength of evidence
  1. weak
  2. moderate
  3. strong

The ladder is an influential conceptual model from strategy and conflict consulting; for the claim about superiority on the next rung, the sources contain no measurement.

  1. 1965
    Theory
    Herman Kahn

    “On Escalation”: a ladder with 44 rungs in seven groups and six thresholds, from the ostensible crisis to uncontrolled war (“spasm or insensate war”).

  2. 1966
    Theory
    Thomas C. Schelling

    “Arms and Influence”: escalation as a form of bargaining with risk.

  3. 1980
    Theory
    Friedrich Glasl

    “Konfliktmanagement” (in German; Conflict Management): nine stages from hardening to “Together into the abyss,” used in mediation and consulting with the aim of de-escalation.

Where the research reaches its limits
  • The ladder assumes that both sides read the rungs in a similar way and act deliberately.
  • In real crises, fear, time pressure and misunderstandings make conflicts skip rungs.
  • Herman Kahn was accused of making the unthinkable seem plannable.
  • In families, teams and churches, deliberate escalation can destroy trust, even if you “win” the conflict.
Read more: what research shows

The model comes from Herman Kahn. In “On Escalation: Metaphors and Scenarios” (1965), he arranged conflicts on a ladder with 44 rungs in seven groups, separated by six thresholds, from the ostensible crisis to uncontrolled nuclear war. He wanted to show that crises can be managed if you know their stages. A year later, in “Arms and Influence,” Thomas C. Schelling described escalation as bargaining with risk. In 1980, in “Konfliktmanagement” (Conflict Management), Friedrich Glasl applied the idea to organizations and relationships; his nine-stage model is used in mediation and consulting to de-escalate. All three are conceptual models. They have not measured whether superiority on the next rung determines the course of a dispute.

The related principles61 Security Dilemma · 64 Credible Commitment · 66 Brinkmanship · 67 Salami Tactics

On the upper rungs, the principle leads to 66 Brinkmanship (a deliberately shared risk)

64 Credible Commitment makes the threat of the next rung credible

67 Salami Tactics deliberately stays below every threshold with small steps

61 Security Dilemma explains why conflicts climb the ladder even without ill intent

Read more: the full text

On the upper rungs, the principle leads to 66 Brinkmanship (a deliberately shared risk); 64 Credible Commitment makes the threat of the next rung credible, and 67 Salami Tactics deliberately stays below every threshold with small steps. 61 Security Dilemma explains why conflicts climb the ladder even without ill intent.

The action steps5 things you can actually do
  1. Define a ladder for your area, from the clarifying conversation to the formal consequence, and make it known before a dispute begins.

  2. Mark the thresholds: where do words turn into deeds, where does a private matter become a public one?
  3. Before every step, ask yourself what response it is likely to trigger from the other side, instead of reflexively escalating by one rung.
  4. Threaten only rungs you really can and want to take.

  5. For every climb, plan a way back down, and offer it as soon as the other side gives way.

The reflection questions3 questions: Does your team know the rungs that will follow in a conflict with you?
  1. Does your team know the rungs that will follow in a conflict with you?
  2. When did you last reflexively escalate by one rung, and what did that trigger?
  3. Which consequence have you already threatened that you would not actually follow through on?

Take your time with one question. Write down your answer – or talk it over with someone you trust.

To finish
The picture to rememberThe animation once more, with an explanation
  1. A ladder of six teal lines stands in the frame, with a gold threshold glowing between two pairs of rungs
  2. Two dots climb higher in turn, growing smaller and paler, until one merely directs a beam at the next rung, where its outline appears large, and the other glides one rung down
Strategy Check

Which rung are you on?

Get your profile across all 12 groups in about 10 to 15 minutes.

Start the Strategy Check
In context

Group 8: Interaction, Alliances and Negotiation

Guiding question: How do you act when others are in the game too?

Stage 4 of 5: Act with others

Where the 92 principles come from: eight traditions of strategy, from classical war theory to dealing with uncertainty.

More about the origin

Background: WEGVISOR’s own selection from the strategy literature · More about the origin

Examples

The principle in practice

From the different spheres of society.

Education

Herman Kahn, “On Escalation” and the Escalation Ladder

In 1965, the American strategist Herman Kahn arranged conflicts on a ladder with 44 rungs, from diplomatic displeasure to nuclear war. His thesis: if you know the rungs and are stronger on the next one, you can steer a conflict instead of being steered by it.

Escalation Ladder
Culture & Sports

Ken Aston, the Yellow and Red Cards and the Escalation Ladder

After a chaotic World Cup match in 1966, the English referee Ken Aston, by his own account, came up with the idea for the yellow and red cards at a traffic light. Since the 1970 World Cup, everyone in the stadium can see which rung of punishment a player is on, and that is exactly what makes a game manageable.

Escalation Ladder
BusinessGovernment

The U.S.–China Trade War and the Escalation Ladder

Starting in July 2018, the United States imposes tariffs on Chinese goods, China responds, and the tariffs rise round by round, from $34 billion to $200 billion worth of goods. The dispute shows how an escalation ladder works in the economy and why the side with more room to maneuver on the next rung has the advantage.

Escalation Ladder
Family

Movie: The War of the Roses

In Danny DeVito’s 1989 black comedy, Oliver and Barbara Rose fight over their house, and every step goes one rung higher than the last. The film shows what happens when both sides see only the next rung and nobody looks for the way down.

Escalation Ladder
FAQ

Questions about the Escalation Ladder

What does the Escalation Ladder say?

Conflicts unfold in stages separated by thresholds. If you know the stages and are credibly stronger on the next one, you can determine the course without having to keep climbing.

Where does the escalation ladder come from?

The model comes from Herman Kahn, who developed it in 1965 in “On Escalation” for crises in the Cold War. Friedrich Glasl later applied the idea to organizations and relationships with a nine-stage model.

What examples are there?

Ken Aston’s yellow and red cards in soccer, the U.S.–China trade war that began in 2018 and the film “The War of the Roses.”

How well is the Escalation Ladder supported by research?

Evidence: weak – the ladder is an influential conceptual model from strategy and conflict consulting; for the claim about superiority on the next rung, the sources contain no measurement.

Your next step

Make strategy effective – together with WEGVISOR

Reading changes how you think. Applying changes your results. Choose how you want to continue.

Request Strategy Coaching

We will get back to you personally.

You came from: Escalation Ladder.